Jump to content

Controversial views unchallenged


Recommended Posts

Women commentators, presenters and summerisers spoil football on tv/radio 

The Championship is a really unfair league

Paul Warne knows that different football is needed in the Championship and he’s not stupid, despite a lot of fans trying to convince me of that. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Posted (edited)

Ebou Adams has been and will hopefully be a brilliant signing, but people mistake his ability to do the job of 2-3 players due to his sheer athleticism - most notable when he kept appearing on the left wing while CBT was hiding after his miss -  as a sign that the manager has got the midfield balance right tactically, but for that to be the case Fornah would have had a similar impact and the two would be almost interchangable.

There's no doubt that he transformed this team but suggestions that we'd have been promoted far earlier if he'd been here all season fall short of the mark because they fail to take into consideration the probability of him missing a large number of games through injury if asked to keep it up over the course of a full season. 5 games in a row without Adams this season and we'd have collapsed completely.

The 'cult of personality' surrounding also  Warne spells doom for whoever eventually replaces him. The whole thing about him being a refreshing change from the norm sets up any following manager,  accidentally or otherwise, for negative comparisons that some won't be able to let go of if he's not as interesting / charming a character as PW is.

Lewis Dobbin was far better than anyone we've bought in since and I'd love him to come back.

Claude Davis was a better defender than Richard Keogh, Keogh's just lucky we never saw him embarrass himself at Premier League level.

Edited by May Contain Nuts
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hiring Phillip Cocu was a colossal mistake.  He was too lazy to study what works in the Championship before taking on the job and too self absorbed and blinkered to recognize that his style of football wasn't working and wouldn't.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I’m going to really miss league one. Not because of the iffy refs or the poor football. But because it feels more like a meritocratic league, like football used to be and how it should be across the board. A good manager and some good players can do well in it without bags of cash. It’s not just 4 or 5 monopolists and then also rans - every season the same like the prem and to an extent the champ - you can go on a run and make a difference. 

and also I think the online world of football fandom can sometimes be quite corrosive and (unintentionally) cruel - this forum included. Not the individual spats about ‘should Warne stay or go’,  or ‘is Sibley a star or failure’ etc, but more that we all fill in huge gaps of time in between actual football matches with speculation and conjecture which, often creates nothing but arguments, doubts among the players, and can be reductive towards staff and even the local reporters - usually based upon very little information or experience but just the need to individually transmit. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

- Steve McClaren was never given a chance to build his own team at Derby and we will never know how good it could've been. His first spell was a team of Nigel Clough's grafters and a load of freebies and loan (conversions). We signed some favourable deals for players like Thorne, Ince, Bent etc way below market value then. He was sacked before Mel splashed cash. HIs second spell involved a January window in which the likes of De Sart and Nugent were signed. Again he was sacked before spending any cash.

- Derby fans unrealistic behaviour derailed our season as much as the injuries did in 2015. Fans aggressive behaviour towards players had a massive impact and some players never recovered. IN particular, the Brighton game where 3-0 up at half time, and fans were abusing Derby players cos (I assume) we didn't score more, started the decline as some of our more fragile players bottled it. Hendrick was abused during the game and then beaten up in Derby town centre, Forsyth was threatened on the touchline, many players were screamed at by idiotic fans for only winning 3-0! Had fans "Been more B4" at that stage, we'd have probably been a Premier League mainstay now.

- Fans treatment of Darren Wassall is a stain on the history of the club. I am still ashamed to this day of the reaction to that Rotherham game.

- Cameron Jerome was massively underrated and even that late into his career, was a great player. We can only dream of a player that good being in our team right now.

- Most football fans attending the game don't seem to be able to grasp how much a negative/aggressive vibe impacts the players. Conversely they cannot grasp that it is much harder to lift the team than it is to crush it.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

https://sportsologygroup.com/articles/the-championship-what-it-takes-to-get-promoted

In the last three seasons, the two highest-spending teams (on player and staff wages) received automatic promotion on two occasions with the first and third highest-spending teams achieving promotion in the other season.

No team outside of the top five highest-spending teams has been promoted in the last 3 seasons.

The lowest wage bill of a promoted team was Brentford (£41.4m) in 2020/21 and the highest wage bill was Fulham (£90.4m) in 2021/22. The average wage bill of a promoted side over these three seasons was £67.1m.

No promoted team in the last three seasons did so without exceeding a 100% wages-to-revenue ratio.

Sources of Talent

Our analysis found that on average the Premier League (27%) was the predominant source of talent for promotion sides followed by other European leagues (25%).

The Championship (18%) itself was surprisingly only the 4th most popular source of talent despite the common narrative around the importance of Championship experience to success in the league.

Squad Construction and Allocation of Minutes

Promotion teams in the last 3 seasons had spent an average of only 1.5 seasons playing together prior to promotion.

Promotion teams had a high influx of new players in the season of promotion, signing an average of 9 new players.

Promotion teams had an average of 3 new signings in their most used 11 players during the season of promotion.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

9 minutes ago, Oldben said:

https://sportsologygroup.com/articles/the-championship-what-it-takes-to-get-promoted

In the last three seasons, the two highest-spending teams (on player and staff wages) received automatic promotion on two occasions with the first and third highest-spending teams achieving promotion in the other season.

No team outside of the top five highest-spending teams has been promoted in the last 3 seasons.

The lowest wage bill of a promoted team was Brentford (£41.4m) in 2020/21 and the highest wage bill was Fulham (£90.4m) in 2021/22. The average wage bill of a promoted side over these three seasons was £67.1m.

No promoted team in the last three seasons did so without exceeding a 100% wages-to-revenue ratio.

Sources of Talent

Our analysis found that on average the Premier League (27%) was the predominant source of talent for promotion sides followed by other European leagues (25%).

The Championship (18%) itself was surprisingly only the 4th most popular source of talent despite the common narrative around the importance of Championship experience to success in the league.

Squad Construction and Allocation of Minutes

Promotion teams in the last 3 seasons had spent an average of only 1.5 seasons playing together prior to promotion.

Promotion teams had a high influx of new players in the season of promotion, signing an average of 9 new players.

Promotion teams had an average of 3 new signings in their most used 11 players during the season of promotion.

You need to update your AI mate - Luton obviously got promoted £27.5m wage bill. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

47 minutes ago, Ambitious said:

You need to update your AI mate - Luton obviously got promoted £27.5m wage bill. 

I'm glad you noted I didn't write a word of it, but had you bothered to read the article instead of trying to out smart the journalist who did write it, you might not bothered replying.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Derby County are one of the few clubs outside the prem elite that neutrals have any interest in no matter how we are doing. The reason why we end up on Sky a lot is because we can drive up viewing figures, Leeds being the only other side I can think of that people will always watch if on TV. Not many sides fall into this bracket, maybe the Sheffield teams and maybe Portsmouth could do but aside that I don’t think there’s many clubs that neutrals really maintain an interest over. 

I have no idea why aside that the atmosphere in PP and ER comes across well on TV which helps maintain interest.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The Brighton and Carlisle pitch invasions were both tinpot. Both games were won and both games finished early because invading the pitch had been fetishised. The Carlisle scenes, though good imagery, were a disgrace.

Southampton was fair enough as that was raw emotion.

Last game at the BBG was also fair enough.

Reading, Charlton and Cardiff were just weird. It was like some hangover from the Southampton pitch invasion that we were entitled to do it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Posted (edited)

Phillip Cocu and Nigel Clough are the only two managers in the past 20 years that cared more about (and prioritised) the wellbeing of the club as opposed to their own personal goals.

Phillip Cocu and Nigel Clough are the only two managers in the past 20 years who could build a team to an identity. 

Phillip Cocu will achieve more in his managerial career (a last 16 Champions League spot and top division title on his resume) than any other Derby manager for the next 50+ years.

Edited by Bris Vegas
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account.

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...