Torquay Utd V Derby Player Ratings

[Ramfan1958]

2 hours ago, hintonsboots said:

 

Dobbin 0 for me pathetic no passion no fight .  

[Ramarena]

Wildsmith 6

Smith 6.5

Cashin 5 

Forsyth 6 

Robert’s 6

Mendez-Laing 6.5

Stearman 5

Sibley 5

Hourihane 4

Bird 4.5

Dobbin 6

Osula 7

Thompson 4

Collins 5

[europia]

Wildsmith - 6

Smith - 6

Cashin - 4

Forsyth - 5

Robert’s - 6

Mendez-Laing - 7.5

Stearman - 5

Sibley - 6

Hourihane - 5.5

Bird - 7

Dobbin - 6.5

Osula - 7.5

Thompson - 5

Collins - 6

[The Scarlet Pimpernel]

4 hours ago, Ellafella said:

Half-marks allowed; please rate all subs. Closes Thursday @ 18:00. Results by Thursday 22:00. Average is 6.00. Therefore, when a sub steps on the pitch he is on 6 - that's the baseline. 

Wildsmith 6

Smith 5

Cashin 4

Forsyth 5

Robert’s 5

Mendez-Laing 5

Spearman 3

Sibley 2

Hourihane 2

Bird 5

Dobbin 4

Osula 4

Thompson  3

Collins 2

 

[gfs1ram]

Wildsmith                    5   Nothing to do but kicking was poor.

Smith                           6

Cashin                         4  Cost us the game.

Forsyth                        6

Robert’s                       6

Mendez-Laing            5  Should have been the match winner but under used and pitch did not help.

Spearman                   5

Sibley                          5  Scared to make a challenge after his 'lucky' yellow card.

Hourihane                   4  Back to normal - no influence.

Bird                              6  Good assist. 

Dobbin                         4  Disappointing. Should have scored at least 1. Should have been subbed imo.

Osula                           6.5  Two good goals. Our only outlet with pace. Should not have been subbed.

Thompson                   5

Collins                          4  Disappointing. Not effective out on the wing needed to be central.

Sending off and penalty changed the game but really we were poor throughout. Should have been out of sight by half time.

 

[i-Ram]

Wildsmith 6

Smith 6

Cashin 5

Forsyth 5

Roberts 6

Mendez-Laing 5

Spearman 4

Sibley 4

Hourihane 4

Bird 5

Dobbin 5

Osula 7

Thompson 4

Collins 6

[MaltRam]

Dobbin was involved again, should have had two, but I have faith it will turn for him.

Hourihane? All that pedigree and experience? Never saw him have any significant impact whatsoever at any time. Is he he for a doss before he packs up or does actually have the desire to compete on a football pitch? He needs to decide before Warne decides for him.

[RoyMac5]

4 minutes ago, Needlesh said:

Dobbin was involved again, should have had two, but I have faith it will turn for him.

Hourihane? All that pedigree and experience? Never saw him have any significant impact whatsoever at any time. Is he he for a doss before he packs up or does actually have the desire to compete on a football pitch? He needs to decide before Warne decides for him.

Hourihane was on at a different phase of the game. But he put in tackles and clearing headers. He's ours and has scored for us. How long do we wait to make a player that isn't ours better?

[VulcanRam]

Wildsmith - 6 ok, though his kicking wasn't as on point as usual

Smith - 6 doing a solid job at RB

Cashin - 4 seems a bit off form at the moment, last few games he's looked a big shaky. Cost us dearly with the shirt tug

Forsyth - 6 lots of heading to do during the second half onslaught 

Roberts - 5 didn't show the same sort of attacking intent as recently.

Mendez-Laing - 7 yet again our only consistent attacking threat. Our performances always go downhill when he goes off, game in game out.

Stearman - 6 will be criticised but did his fair share of hacking and heading in the last half hour

Sibley - 4.5 ineffective and could possibly have seen red, though yellow was the right call imo

Hourihane - 5 didn't add anything when he came on

Bird - 5 very little impact

Dobbin - 5 no end product, rinse and repeat

Osula - 7.5 took his goals really well

Thompson - 5 added nowt 

Collins - 5 inconspicuous throughout, seemed to be out wide too much to really impact the game 

 

 

[CBRammette]

Wildsmith 6

Smith 6

Cashin 4

Forsyth 5

Roberts 6.5

Mendez-Laing 6

Spearman 4

Sibley 4

Hourihane 3

Bird 5 only for assist

Dobbin 4.5

Osula 7

Thompson 5

Collins 5

[Yani P]

I'm impressed someone can get a 4 when they score our two goals and get subbed off early..

[alfaskye]

14 hours ago, Ellafella said:

All very ordinary, looked like game could have been on the racecourse on Sunday morning.

Wildsmith 6 calm, poor kicking 

Smith 6

Cashin 6.5 thought he was better than other posters, got to lots of through balls

Forsyth 6

Roberts 6.5

Mendez-Laing 6.5 should have stayed on, best threat

Stearman 6

Sibley 6

Hourihane 3 shouldn't be considered 

Bird 5

Dobbin 6.5 if only he could see the goal

Osula 6.5

Thompson 3

Collins 6

 

[Crewton]

Wildsmith    7  Generally dealt well with aerial bombardment. Maybe could have done better on the penalty?

Smith          6.5  Played well for most of the game, including getting forward.

Cashin        5    Defended well whilst on the pitch, but has to be marked down for the sending off.

Forsyth     6  Generally dealt well with aerial bombardment.

Robert’s   6.5  Like Smith, I thought he generally played well.

Mendez-Laing   7  Gave Moxey a torrid time. Substitution was understandable but made us weaker.

Stearman    4  Not his usual calm self, but then hasn't played much recently.

Sibley   6   Generally OK, I don't think the booking was really justified but it meant we couldn't risk him for the whole game.

Hourihane   3   Poor, but he's not someone you'd ordinarily bring on to "save" a match is he?

Bird   6  I thought he was MotM until the sending off, dealing well with the physical side, but showed he's not really a DM during the siege and still not quite a leader.

Dobbin   5.5   I'd give him 9/10 for approach play, but 2/10 for finishing. Missed an easy header and isn't testing keepers enough.

Osula  7/10  Two excellent goals but showed he struggles as a target man.

Thompson  6  Unlike most it seems, I though he put himself about well, considering the ball was usually 60ft above his head.

Collins  6  Another who was great until the sending off, then struggled to do the basics afterwards.

[Premier ram]

was at game

 

                        Wildsmith-6

                        Smith-7

                        Cashin-5

                        Fozzy-7

                        Roberts-6

                        Bird-5.5

                        Sibley-6

                        NML-5.5

                        Dobbin-5.5

                        Osula-7

                        Collins-5.5

                        Stearman-5

                        Hourihane-5

                        Thommo-5

[rammieib]

Wildsmith - 6

Smith - 6

Cashin - 4

Forsyth - 6

Robert’s - 5

Mendez-Laing - 7

Stearman - 5

Sibley - 6

Hourihane - 5

Bird - 6

Dobbin - 6

Osula - 8

Thompson - 4

Collins - 6

[angieram]

Wildsmith 6

Smith 5

Cashin 5

Forsyth 6

Robert’s 6.5

Mendez-Laing 7

Spearman 5

Sibley 5

Hourihane 4

Bird ? 6

Dobbin 6

Osula 7

Thompson 6

Collins 6

Was at the game

[Jimbo Ram]

19 hours ago, The Scarlet Pimpernel said:

 

Osula 4 ?

[Steve Buckley’s Dog]

Wildsmith-6

Smith-6

Cashin-4

Forsyth-6

Robert’s-6

Mendez-Laing-6

Spearman-6

Sibley-6 (barely touched him)

Hourihane-4 

Bird-6

Dobbin-5

Osula-7

Thompson -5

Collins-4

We aren’t very good are we. Maybe Knight will be back for the replay. He might be centre half after Fozzy and Stearman get sent off against Liverpool/MK Dons. Penalty! 

[Jimbo Ram]

23 hours ago, i-Ram said:

Wildsmith 6

Smith 6

Cashin 5

Forsyth 5

Roberts 6

Mendez-Laing 5

Spearman 4

Sibley 4

Hourihane 4

Bird 5

Dobbin 5

Osula 7

Thompson 4

Collins 6

Mendez Laing was our best player first half wasn’t he ?

[i-Ram]

14 minutes ago, Jimbo Ram said:

Mendez Laing was our best player first half wasn’t he ?

Really? He beat Moxey a few times, but did he deliver any meaningful chance to anyone else in the team. He created one chance for himself where he lashed it over, when very well placed.