Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

Half marks allowed; please rate all subs. Closes Monday @18:00; results by Monday 22:00
Average is 6.00. Therefore when a sub steps on the pitch he is on 6 - that's the baseline. 

Wildsmith

Knight

Stearman

Cashin 

Forsyth

Bird

Hourihane

Mendez-Laing

Barkhuizen

Collins

Dobbin

Subs from:

Sibley

McGoldrick

Posted

Wildsmith 6 Can only remember 1 shot to save. 

Knight 7.5 Should've scored with a header

Stearman 7 should've scored with a header

Cashin 7.5 two stray passes; some lovely Bucko-esque cross-field passes to NML

Forsyth 7.5 Some good crosses in

Bird 7.5 Good shift

Hourihane 6 Need more end product

Mendez-Laing 8 motm High energy & constant threat

Barkhuizen 5.5 Need more end product

Collins 7 Doing lots of work but feeding off very little

Dobbin 6.5 Bright early on took a knock and faded

Subs from:

Sibley 8 Made a difference off the bench; unlucky with shots/crosses

McGoldrick 6.5 Getting up to speed still. 

Our lack of goals is now starting to look structural not just bad luck. This team starting to look Cocu-esque. 

Posted

Wildsmith 7

 

Knight 8

 

Stearman 7

 

Cashin 7

 

Forsyth 7.5

 

Bird 7.5

 

Hourihane 7

 

Mendez-Laing 8

 

Barkhuizen 7

 

Collins 6.5

 

Dobbin 7

 

Subs from:

 

Sibley 8

 

McGoldrick 7

Posted

Wildsmith      6.5

Knight            7.5

Stearman       7

Cashin           7

Forsyth         6

Bird               6.5

Hourihane       6.5

Mendez-Laing      7.5

Barkhuizen       6.5

Collins            5.5

Dobbin           6

Subs from:

Sibley            7.5

McGoldrick     6.5

Posted

Wildsmith       7 

Knight             7.5

Stearman        7

Cashin             7.5

Fozzy               7

Bird                   7.5

Hourihane         7

Nml                    7. 5

Barkhuizen         7

Collins                 6.5 

Dobbin                7

Sibley                  7.5

McGoldrick          7

Posted (edited)
4 hours ago, Ellafella said:

Half marks allowed; please rate all subs. Closes Monday @18:00; results by Monday 22:00
Average is 6.00. Therefore when a sub steps on the pitch he is on 6 - that's the baseline. 

Wildsmith 6

Knight 6.5

Stearman 7

Cashin 7

Forsyth 7

Bird 7.5

Hourihane 7.5

Mendez-Laing 7

Barkhuizen 6

Collins 6

Dobbin 6.5

Subs from:

Sibley 6.5

McGoldrick 6.5

 

Edited by sage
Posted

Wildsmith - 6. Very little to do. Looks nervous coming off his line. 
Knight -7. Good going forward, lots of energy, should have scored with header. 
Cashin -6. Steady as ever. 
Stearman -6. Does the simple things well. Almost caught out but got awarded a FK. Lucky. 
Fozzy - 7. Good performance. Crossing always a danger. 
Hourihane - 6. Not his day today. Couple of decent chances fluffed. 
Bird - 6. Doesn’t score (or look like scoring) Doesn’t assist (or look like assisting.)  Should not be captain. 
NML- 8. Pace, Power and direct. Frightens defenders to death. MOTM. Barkhuizen - 6. Needs to find a end product. 
Dobbin - 7. Lively, direct. Unlucky not to score or assist in first half. Going to be a player this season. 
Collins - 6. Simply needs a goal. Nothing coming off for him. 
 

Sibley -7. Excellent cameo. Needs to produce this form from the start when given the opportunity. Most likely match winner in last 10 minutes. 

Posted

Wildsmith 7

Knight 6.5

Stearman 7

Cashin 7

Forsyth 6.5

Bird 7

Hourihane 7

Mendez-Laing 6.5 

Barkhuizen 6.5

Collins 6

Dobbin 6.5

Subs from:

Sibley 7

McGoldrick 6

 

Weirdly, I’m not sure who I’d award MOTM to, probably Bird.

Posted

was at the game

 

                               Wildsmith-7

                               Knight-7.5

                               Stearman-7.5

                               Cashin-8

                               Fozzy-7

                               Bird-6.5

                               Hourihane-6

                               Barkhuizen-6.5

                               NML-7

                               Dobbin-7.5

                               Collins-6

                               Mcgoldrick-6

                               Sibley-7.5

Posted (edited)

Wildsmith   6 - quiet game, decent shot stopping, nervy corners

Knight   7 - yet another good game, plenty forward runs, could have scored

Stearman   7 - Curtis who?

Cashin   7 - another solid performance

Forsyth   7 - got forward, delivered some excellent crosses

Bird   6 - think I give him 6 every week. Does his job but needs to do more

Hourihane   7 - busy, got in good positions, pity he couldnt bury a 30 yarder

Mendez-Laing   8 - had a dip last time out, looked a real threat again vs Fleetwood

Barkhuizen   6 - got talent when hes on it but quiet and ineffective for long periods

Collins   6 - puts himself about, probably could lurk nearer the 6yd box more, great turn and shot top corner save by keeper

Dobbin   7 - fast n furious!  Gonna be a threat now hes up to speed

SUBS:

Sibley   7 - unfortunately getting tagged as a super sub, made an impact again when he came on

McGoldrick   6 - expecting more, hopefully will come with more game time

How did we not win this?  Back to front we're looking really solid, a couple of extra goals recently and we could have easily been 3rd on goal difference.  MOre attacking line up and it showed, just need the breaks now.  And a good end to the transfer window...

EDIT: RamsTV

Edited by maxjam
Posted

Thank you once again for your ratings and comments. We received 16 sets of scores this week which is below par & compares with 33 V Barnsley, 26 V Oxford Utd, 25 V Shrewsbury Town, 15 v Charlton and 9 v Mansfield.

Summary

 The infographic is below. You rated Mendez-Laing as {statistical} MotM with an average of 7.35. Next highest was Knight with 7.23. The average rating was 6.76 with 8 players above the Team Average and 5 below it. The red dotted line shows the cut-off.  A trend is starting to emerge with Collins, Barkheuizen, & Hourihane tending to be consistently below the average. At the opposite end, Mendez-Laing, Knight, Cashin and Sibley tend to be consistently the highest. Early days yet still.

Interesting to note that highest rates this match are given to players who have been at Derby more than a season - except for Mendez- Laing. Probably not a bias just a reflection of performance.

Average Team Aggregate rating was 87.9; Milleniumram got the "Tony Hatch" award for being 7.9 points lower than this. Lowest rating was awarded by thekingofbuxton with Collins rated at 4.00.

I'm dying to get a "season to date" analysis posted; it may be tonight although as I've been working today since 8 am and it's now almost 8pm I may not manage it.   

Comments, suggestions, questions all welcome. 

Thanks again for your help. Up the Rams!

 

 

infographic FTFC.jpg

Posted

Thanks, @Ellafella.

A comment on the lower ratings. I feel Collins and Barkhuizen are working really hard but things aren't quite coming off for them.

Hourihane for me is coasting a bit, very casual at times on the ball. I expected more from him, most room for improvement,  imo.

You'll probably get less ratings at away matches as fewer of us were actually there. Good work, though  thank you.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account.

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...