Jump to content

Shrewsbury Town V Derby County: Ratings


Ellafella

Recommended Posts

 

Half marks allowed; please rate all subs. Closes Thursday @18:00; results by Thursday 22:00
Average is 6.00. Therefore when a sub steps on the pitch he is on 6 - that's the baseline. 

Wildsmith

Knight

Stearman

Cashin 

Roberts

Korey-Smith

Bird

Hourihane

Mendez-Laing

Barkhuizen

Collins

Subs from:

Sibley

Dobbin

Forsyth

Rooney

Anang

Thompson

McGoldrick

 

Edited by Ellafella
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Wildsmith       6

Knight             7

Stearman        7

Cashin            7

Roberts            6

Korey-Smith     5

Bird                  5

Hourihane        5

Mendez-Laing    6

Barkhuizen       6.5

Collins              5

Subs from:

Sibley              6

Dobbin           7.5

Forsyth            6

Rooney

Anang

Thompson

McGoldrick      5.5

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Wildsmith 7 not a lot to do but looked composed

Knight 7.5 his usual energy filled game

Stearman 8 very good, should have scored but was our best defender today

Cashin 7 solid again, bailed out by his mate a couple of times

Roberts 6 was ok nothing spectacular

Korey-Smith 6.5 thought he was decent while he was on..improving..

Bird 6 fairly quiet game but some nice interlink play

Hourihane 5 set pieces not great and a fair few sloppy passes - unusual filor him

Mendez-Laing 6 did ok

Barkhuizen 6 same ok if not spectacular

Collins 5 anonymous really

Sibley 6 had a glorious chance to win the game, did ok

Dobbin 6.5 pace to burn..one superb precision pass opened them up

McGoldrick 6 decent start for him

Fozzy 6 not on too long so solid 6

Edited by Yani P
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Wildsmith 6 had Jack to do.

Knight 7.5 get him in his proper position

Stearman 7.5 A good shift

Cashin 7.5 Assured. 

Roberts 6.5 Steady

Korey-Smith 6 Passed him by a bit again.

Bird 7 Needs a better impactful game soon

Hourihane 7 some good balls in

Mendez-Laing 5 below par tonight

Barkhuizen 5 below par tonight

Collins 5 fed off scraps

Subs from:

Sibley 7 had the best chance which drew a good save 

Dobbin 7.5 looked very lively and sharp; perhaps the ray of light of the night

Forsyth 6 a late covering shift

McGoldrick 7.5 bright and got a tame header in 

Edited by Ellafella
Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, Ellafella said:

 

Half marks allowed; please rate all subs. Closes Thursday @18:00; results by Thursday 22:00
Average is 6.00. Therefore when a sub steps on the pitch he is on 6 - that's the baseline. 

Wildsmith 6

Knight 6

Stearman 6

Cashin 7 MOTM

Roberts 6

Korey-Smith 6

Bird 6

Hourihane 6

Mendez-Laing 5

Barkhuizen 5

Collins 5

Subs from:

Sibley 6

Dobbin 6

Forsyth 6

Rooney

Anang

Thompson

McGoldrick 6

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 hours ago, Ellafella said:

 

Half marks allowed; please rate all subs. Closes Thursday @18:00; results by Thursday 22:00
Average is 6.00. Therefore when a sub steps on the pitch he is on 6 - that's the baseline. 

Wildsmith 7

Knight 6.5

Stearman 7

Cashin 7

Roberts 6.5

Korey-Smith 5.5

Bird 6

Hourihane 6.5

Mendez-Laing 5 5

Barkhuizen 6

Collins 5.5

Subs from:

Sibley 6

Dobbin 7

Forsyth 6

Rooney

Anang

Thompson

McGoldrick 6.5

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Wildsmith   6 - quiet night

Knight   7 -  another solid performance, unfortunately ? 

Stearman   7 - solid again

Cashin   7 - setting a baseline performance of above average!

Roberts   6 - did okay

Smith   6 - better than the weekend but needs to do more

Bird   6 - key position, needs to impose himself more

Hourihane   6 - a few good passes/crosses but needed more

Mendez-Laing   6  - looked tired after the weekend

Barkhuizen   6 - as above

Collins   5 - very quiet night

SUBS:

Sibley   7 - best of the subs, tempo picks up when hes on the pitch

Dobbin   7 - his best performance, can see him getting a lot better

Forsyth   6 - helped see the game out

McGoldrick   6 - first appearance, reasonable start, will get better

Watched on RamsTV, solid if uninspiring performance.  Good to see us complete in the 2nd half rather than wilt as per the last few games.  On balance probably should have won it, but could also have lost it.  Take the point and move on.  Gotta win away at Fleetwood imo, get the away hoodoo off our back and get into the top 6 before a run of home games.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Wildsmith 6 - Didn't have anything to do. 

Knight 5.5 - Not much to do defensively. So many times he got the ball in space, looked up ignored a pass and then passed back to Stearman. The 1 time he passed inside quickly, we should have scored. Don't like his playing/diving for free kicks generally, and doing so in your own box is too dangerous. 

Stearman 6 - Solid defensively. Frustrating watching him repeatedly choose the two yard pass to Wildsmith who then passes it two yards to Cashin, rather than pass to Cashin himself. So much of our passing along the backline is slow and does nothing to move the opposition around. 

Cashin 6.5 - Solid as always. Unless he has a big downturn in form, should be a guaranteed starter. 

Roberts 6 - Started brightly, nice quick passing with Bird to get us through the lines. This seemed to stop after about 25 minutes.

Smith 5.5 - Neat and tidy but he just gives it straight back to the man who's passed it to him 95% of the time, not suited to where he's being played. Poor selection. 

Bird 6.5 - He really needs to start demanding the ball more, without him getting on it, the passing is so slow. 

Hourihane 5 - Got worse as the game went on, his passing lacked the composure you'd expect from him. Pass wasn't good enough for the Barkhuizen chance and possibly the wrong choice.

Mendez-Laing 5 - Not in the game much and seemed more reluctant to take his man on. 

Barkhuizen 5.5 - Got in some good positions but opted not to cross most times and pass back to Hourihane. Can be an effective tactic at times with Hourihane's crossing but often it just led to a positive move losing momentum.  

Collins 5 - Struggled, poor service and couldn't get in to the game. Nice dummy and run for the Barkhuizen chance. 

Subs from:

Sibley 6.5 - Not a winger, but still was lively. Should have started. Had probably our best chance.

Dobbin 7.5 - Excellent, beat players so easily with pace and quick feet. Created the chance for Sibley, will be pushing for a start. 

Forsyth 6 - One nice pass in to the box which ended with a Sibley shot.

McGoldrick 5.5 - Could tell he'd only played 45 minutes of pre-season, lacking match sharpness. Some signs of how good he'll be if he stays fit. Ruined a real good break opportunity with a rushed pass.

Edited by ben_dcfc
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account.

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...