Mick Brolly

25 minutes ago, Chris_Martin said:

 

 

Lets be honest, the clean sheet was a touch fortunate. They did hit the post and accumulated 1xg to our 1.2xg, as well as having more shots.

The 3 goals were good quality, but the problem is that there is just no pattern of play to either our attacking or defending. We just completely rely on moments of brilliance from a NML or Bird for example. It's identical in that regard to Didzy last season. We are basically the man utd version of league one. No identity, no pattern of play, fairly boring to watch, heavily reliant on moments from individuals, and just getting enough results to keep us near the top.  

Like that moment of individual brilliance from Collins against Cheltenham.

Barnsley sold out 

8 minutes ago, bimmerman said:

There's something about him I just don't like. Not as a player, he's pretty good, just don't like him

I assume from this opinion that you have met him then 

37 minutes ago, Jimbo Ram said:

I don’t think it is Warne bashing, it’s nothing against him personally, seems like a nice chap; if anything it’s more performance bashing 😊

There are a few on here who seem to make it personal by scrutinizing every word in his interviews and calling him a clown and criticising his personality,clothing etc 

1 hour ago, Caerphilly Ram said:

I feel like there’s little point debating it anymore. Those who have concerns about Warne have set their stall, those who are willing to give it more time have set theirs and the pages of to and fro across the forum make it very clear there’s little movement in those mindsets and not much by way of persuasion being considered.

I’m not arguing in support of Warne or saying he should be everyone’s choice for manager, it’s the proverbial p*ssing in the wind at this point, with many holding valid concerns which they’ve expressed many times over.

Results and performances are the only things that will make a difference to those entrenched in either view, and even then, as @TomTom92 said in another thread yesterday, I think it’s plain that Warne just isn’t for some people and regardless of what he does or doesn’t achieve there’s plenty who’ll be glad to see him go when the time comes. I just hope he gets the team promoted and whoever does replace him, whenever and however Warne leaves, perhaps proves less divisive of a character.

Amen to that but you won't stop the constant Warne bashing all day every day by some on here.

4 minutes ago, VulcanRam said:

Wilson didn't pick the wrong starting line up, Warne did. 

Wilson didn't make the ridiculous decision to take Nyambe off, Warne did. (Nothing about his body language suggested he couldn't have lasted the last 5 mins).

And, and I accept I may be alone in this, it wasn't Wilson's decision to sit back and try to defend for 25 minutes having gone a goal ahead against team whose away record is extremely poor and leave CBT on the bench when we were crying out for some spark. 

It was however, Wilson who let his man go. So that's 3-1. 

I'm with @DavesaRam on this. It was poor management yesterday.

Anyway, this thread is for positives. It was a better performance than against Cheltenham. South stand was noiser. Adams is great. Bird has turned up since Adams did. It wasn't so cold. I got home about 10 mins earlier than usual as the traffic didn't seem as bad as it can be. The ref was excellent for the first 15 seconds.  

Nyambe was injured wasn’t he?

30 minutes ago, Rambam said:

Like Arteta stood next to Pep, Steve stood next to Arteta. 
Get him in, I say. Local guy, with previous ties to our club. 

You want to get him in now?

1 hour ago, DavesaRam said:

The greatest difficulty is watching us muller Shrewsbury, get the lead, then stop and shut up shop. Ot was a stupid decision by Mr Warne. The dropped points are on him.

Nothing to do with Wilson then

1 hour ago, Ian Buxton's Bat said:

listened to RD on way back.

Mystic Malcolm predicted PW wouldn’t admit it was a bad sub……and he was correct 

 

He was injured 

2 hours ago, Fuertes’s Passport said:

Absolutely. More idiocy from a truly inept tactician. Rancid football - predictable and ponderous in attack . All the clapping the fans and trying to become the next Ian Holloway with media friendly antics  cannot hide the fact that he is a truly terrible coach . We should wipe out Shrewsbury ( themselves an appalling team ) with the players at his disposal .What does he actually do all week ? 

What a great post you certainly know your football 

41 minutes ago, WystonRam said:

Poor decision to take Nyambe off, at that particular period of the game.  I went bonkers at the time and sadly was right. It is hugely irritating , Warne made a point in his post match interview to say the substitution wasn’t to blame, it was.

Should have left him on to make injury worse and rule him out for the rest of the season 

4 hours ago, RoyMac5 said:

Yeah Derby are great. 🍺

This is a thread about Warne. 👍

You make every thread about Warne 

1 hour ago, RoyMac5 said:

Apparently we can only sign players better than the ones other teams have recruited? An odd process. 😄 

Wonder what direction this thread will take 

2 minutes ago, tinman said:

The question was how do we change it up? 
the answer I gave was change the manager. 
 

or only answers approved by you allowed?

The question was how do we change it up with what we've got if it's to challenging for you to post a sensible reply don't bother 

5 minutes ago, tinman said:

Change the manager

What a surprise some tit is straight on turning it into a anti Warne thread with the usual bore Roy mac applauding it ducking grow up you're ruining the forum for others

9 hours ago, Millenniumram said:

What a thoroughly depressing time to be a Derby fan. Good luck Max, you deserve better than this club and this management.

If You hate everything about something so much surely it's time to find something else to do with your time 

32 minutes ago, valakari said:

Tell me 1 fan that enjoys Warnes brand of football...after virtually every game, we have come away saying, "we got away with that"..or, "we won but the football was dire"

Love when someone thinks they are the voice of 30,000 people 

19 minutes ago, YorkshireRam said:

You really do have a strange habit of making even innocuous comments seem like you're trying to sneak an underhanded jibe in 😂

There are a few posters who turn every thread into a dig at Warne thread quite pathetic really 

40 minutes ago, Millenniumram said:

Good signing, fits in with the rest of Warne’s recruitment. I did think the treatment table was getting a bit empty.

Why do you even bother if that's all you can come up with 

29 minutes ago, RoyMac5 said:

Well we didn't manage to attract a striker bar gambles on TJJ, Washy and Waggy so most of it gone before them? Now who knows, didn't Warne say he didn't want to offer more for Smith?

That the position our restrictions have put us in.

19 minutes ago, S8TY said:

i get what you're saying but wheel and deal , sell Cashin and Bird if it means getting a few in that will matter, why is everyone so hung up on keeping our two academy products, would Brentford or Posh not sell and spend the money or reinvest etc ....Both of those players are not irreplaceable no one is in fact ...Bird could well be walking around PP at the end of the season waving goodbye when we could've used that money wisely, but here lies the problem for me...Warne does not seem to sign wisely so I'm with you , lets stay as we are and try and try and get up with what we have ................may well be in L1 though next season 

Personally don't think it would be wise to sell bird or Cashin at this point in the season could backfire massively if we bought in a couple of duds or someone who picks up a season ending injury  

20 minutes ago, RoyMac5 said:

How much of our budget for the season do you think he spent on his summer signings?

How much do you think 

1 hour ago, trappatoni said:

When has he said tactically he got it wrong?  

 

When ? What faults has he admitted to ?   Im not talking about some vague collective responsibility line - I'm talking about analysing a poor performance in terms other than blaming the players for being below par.  

That's fine just carry on with your one sided agenda/argument 

50 minutes ago, trappatoni said:

 

He never takes responsibility.   If we perform poorly it's players below par, losing their battles, not doing the basics.   

I don't buy it - one week Bird can pass a ball and the next week he can't?    Yes players will make mistakes within a game, misplace a pass, let their man go, lose a tackle - but if it isn't working for them consistently within a game it's probably not them but something within the game that the manager could change.    

I've heard him take responsibility in many of his after match interviews 

5 minutes ago, David said:

Wasn’t great was it. The goals were, the rest not so.

3 points in the bag though, that’s all matters at this stage of the season.

What about trawling through every single word the manager says after the game and using it as a stick to beat him with surly that's more important than 3 points.