Derby County v Lincoln City: Player Ratings

[Ellafella]

Half-marks allowed; please rate all subs. Closes Thursday @ 18:00. Results by Thursday 22:00. Average is 6.00. Therefore, when a sub steps on the pitch he is on 6 - that's the baseline.

1Wildsmith

12Smith

3Forsyth

6Cashin

15Roberts

17 Sibley

38Knight

4Hourihane

11Mendez-Laing

10McGoldrick

18Dobbin

7Barkhuizen

9Collins

23White

[CBRammette]

Cant face it yet

[Rampant]

1Wildsmith         6.5

12Smith              6.5

3Forsyth            7.5

6Cashin             4.5

15Roberts          5

17 Sibley            6.5

38Knight          6.5

4Hourihane        6.5

11Mendez-Laing      6

10McGoldrick      6.5

18Dobbin           6

7Barkhuizen       6.5

9Collins           4.5

23White          6.5

Edited February 14, 2023 by Rampant

[Ellafella]

6 minutes ago, CBRammette said:

Cant face it yet

@sagelikes to go first any road ?

Edited February 14, 2023 by Ellafella

[Guest]

1Wildsmith 6.5 (couple of decent stops and not really to blame for the goal)

12Smith 6 (tried hard but right-side was a source of frustration!)

3Forsyth 7 (solid enough)

6Cashin 6.5 (a bit wayward by his usual high standards)

15Roberts 5.5 (too many misplaced passes; down a notch on recent performances)

17 Sibley 6.5 (hit the bar and a mixture of crosses - some good some not)

38Knight 6 (can never fault his effort but not much came off)

4Hourihane 7 (goal - offside like the Lincoln one? Maybe. Second half much better than first. Still doesn’t deliver enough on set pieces)

11Mendez-Laing 5.5 (so frustrating tonight and really poor leading up to Lincoln goal. Worked hard but a rare poor showing from him)

10McGoldrick 6.5 (worked hard. Looked onside to me for the “winner”)

18Dobbin 6 (couldn’t get into the game but would have preferred to see NML hooked at half-time)

7Barkhuizen 6 (one decent cross for McG “goal” but not enough impact besides)

9Collins 5.5 (will never fault his effort but little to show for it)

23White 7 (very tidy, kept us ticking over and only the occasional more ambitious pass failed to come off)

[sage]

18 minutes ago, Ellafella said:

Half-marks allowed; please rate all subs. Closes Thursday @ 18:00. Results by Thursday 22:00. Average is 6.00. Therefore, when a sub steps on the pitch he is on 6 - that's the baseline.

1Wildsmith 6.5

12Smith 6.5

3Forsyth 7

6Cashin 5

15Roberts 5.5

17 Sibley 5.5

38Knight 5.5

4Hourihane 6.5

11Mendez-Laing 6

10McGoldrick 6.5

18Dobbin 6

7Barkhuizen 7

9Collins 6

23White 6.5

 

[kevinhectoring]

1Wildsmith  6.5

12Smith  6

3Forsyth 7.5

6Cashin  6.5

15Roberts 6

17 Sibley 7

38Knight 6.5

4Hourihane 6.5

11Mendez-Laing 6 

10McGoldrick 6.5

18Dobbin  6

7Barkhuizen 6.5

9Collins  5.5

23White 7 

[Magicman]

Fozzy 8 the rest 5s 

[bcnram]

1Wildsmith         6

12Smith              5

3Forsyth            7

6Cashin             5

15Roberts          4

17 Sibley            6

38Knight           7

4Hourihane        6

11Mendez-Laing      4

10McGoldrick      6

18Dobbin           6

7Barkhuizen       6

9Collins            5

23White          7

[rammieib]

1Wildsmith         6.5

12Smith              6 (should have done better with chance first half - I’m critical but zero goals, zero assists this season?)

3Forsyth            7 (very solid - Couple of Miskicks only)

6Cashin             5.5 (reality check)

15Roberts          5 (crossing was atrocious)

17 Sibley            6.5 (get forward man!)

38Knight          6.5

4Hourihane        7.5 (genuinely thought he was the one driving us on tonight)

11Mendez-Laing      5

10McGoldrick      6

18Dobbin           5.5

7Barkhuizen       7 (good cameo - get him back in the starting 11)

9Collins           6

23White          6.5 (too scared to play a longer ball and bypass players quicker)

[CBRammette]

1Wildsmith  6

12Smith  5  terrible final ball/decisions

3Forsyth 7

6Cashin  5.5

15Roberts 5

17 Sibley 6.5 unlucky off the bar

38Knight 6.5

4Hourihane 6.5

11Mendez-Laing 5

10McGoldrick 5.5 with a totally useless linesman second half just asking to be called offside - inevitable if we scored

18Dobbin  5.5

7Barkhuizen 6.5

9Collins  6 worked hard

23White 6.5

[Yani P]

Wildsmith 7

12Smith 5.5

3Forsyth 8

6Cashin 4

15Roberts 6

17 Sibley 6

38Knight 5.5

4Hourihane 6.5

11Mendez-Laing 6

10McGoldrick 6.5

18Dobbin 6

7Barkhuizen 6

9Collins 4.5

23White 6.5

[Rich84]

7 hours ago, Ellafella said:

Half-marks allowed; please rate all subs. Closes Thursday @ 18:00. Results by Thursday 22:00. Average is 6.00. Therefore, when a sub steps on the pitch he is on 6 - that's the baseline.

1Wildsmith 6

12Smith 5 as said by others, not good enough delivery when against 10 men

3Forsyth 7 bailed Cashin out more than once

6Cashin 5 his worst game imo

15Roberts 4.5 oh dear

17 Sibley 6.5 2 poor crosses, but generally a better option from fb than Roberts and Smith

38Knight 6, poor until moved further fwds

4Hourihane 7 grew into game but set piece delivery still not good enough for a supposed quality player 

11Mendez-Laing 5, shouldn't have started imo, been off it for few games, needs a rest, Surprised he stayed on

10McGoldrick 6, his poor game still average at this level

18Dobbin 6, unlucky to be off instead of NML although not good himself 

7Barkhuizen 6, huffed and puffed

9Collins 5, works hard but doesn't look like a threat 

23White 6.5, tidy, and 1 crucial tackle to stop breakaway 

 

[VulcanRam]

1Wildsmith 6

12Smith 6

3Forsyth 6

6Cashin 5

15Roberts 5

17 Sibley 6

38Knight 6

4Hourihane 6

11Mendez-Laing 5

10McGoldrick 5

18Dobbin 5

7Barkhuizen 6

9Collins 5

23White 6

[Carnero]

1Wildsmith         6

12Smith              6

3Forsyth            8

6Cashin             5

15Roberts          5

17 Sibley            7

38Knight          6.5

4Hourihane        7

11Mendez-Laing      5

10McGoldrick     7

18Dobbin           5

7Barkhuizen       6.5

9Collins           5

23White          6.5

[Day]

1 Wildsmith - 7

12 Smith - 5

3 Forsyth - 8

6 Cashin - 5

15 Roberts - 4

17 Sibley - 6

38 Knight - 6

4 Hourihane - 6

11Mendez-Laing - 5

10 McGoldrick - 5

18 Dobbin - 4

7 Barkhuizen - 6

9 Collins - 4

23 White - 6

[1of4]

Wildsmith:-6.5

Smith:-6.5

Forsyth:-7.5

Cashin:-6

Roberts:-6

Knight:-6.5

Hourihane:-6.5

Mendez-Laing:-6

McGoldrick:-6.5

Dobbin:-6

Collins:-6

Barkhuizen:-6

White:-6

Sibley:-6

[gfs1ram]

12 hours ago, Ellafella said:

 

1Wildsmith                    7    Did nothing wrong. couple of good saves.

12Smith                        5     not his recent self. arguing with NML a lot first half

3Forsyth                      7.5     just MoM on basis of fewer mistakes 

6Cashin                       3     Just very poor. Worst he has played.

15Roberts                   3     Again very poor, nothing like his last few games

17 Sibley                     6    A few wayward crosses but at least got forward. Hit crossbar.

 38Knight                   5    Maybe early booking effected his game. Not usual self.

4Hourihane                6   Steady when most around him were falling apart

11Mendez-Laing       5   Not much joy against his fullback. Lucky not to be subbed.

10McGoldrick           6   Seemed to be trying too hard but still our most likeliest scorer.

18Dobbin                  5  Showed good pace at times bit unlucky to be subbed.

7Barkhuizen             5  Should have scored and super cross for Didzy 'goal'

9Collins                    6  Thought he was ok in a poor first half, without threatening to score (as usual)

23White                   6  Added some composure to midfield.

What an awful match to watch. Thought Lincoln did a good job on Derby first half by closing us down. Far too many not 'on song'. Slow build up , poor passing. Lincoln a yard quicker to the ball. Never seen Cashin play so poorly, concerning, didn't think he had that in him. West Stand Linesman shockingly bad. Still should have won it second half. Not Warne's best tactical match.  We move on.

 

 

[Hoppo]

Wildsmith 6.5 Not a lot to do but solid as always. Particularly liked his block from their shot where he flicked it up in the air and caught it with one hand looking Cool as.

12Smith 6 Started well in the first half but dwindled as the match progressed

3Forsyth 7 Solid performance

6Cashin 5.5 Just a lot of bad touches and positioning. Possibly his worst performance so far in a Derby shirt.

15Roberts 6 Poor relative to recent performances.

17 Sibley 6.5 Made a difference when came on.

38Knight 6 Bang average.

4Hourihane 6.5 Average performance. Extra .5 for the goal.

11Mendez-Laing 5.5 As Cahsin, probably worst performance I've seen him in a Derby shirt. Giving away the ball for their goal wasn't the only really poor touch he made, there were quite a few. Would have marked him lower but he did a lot of good things as well.

10McGoldrick 6.5 Standard, only player on the pitch who looked like he might make things happen last night.

18Dobbin 6 Their right back had him in his pocket somehow.

7Barkhuizen 6 Looked good when he came on, lifted the attack.

9Collins 5 He looked laboured in the first half. Needs a rest

23White 6.5 Looks competent. I'd like to see what he could do over 90 minutes.

 

[Ramarena]

1Wildsmith         6.5

12Smith              6

3Forsyth            7

6Cashin             5

15Roberts          5.5

17 Sibley            6.5

38Knight          6.5

4Hourihane        6.5

11Mendez-Laing      5.5

10McGoldrick      6

18Dobbin           6

7Barkhuizen       6.5

9Collins           4.5

23White            7