Southampton vs Derby FA Cup 3rd Round Replay match thread

[Gritstone Ram]

When I saw the replay I thought it was offside. We have played better in the last 20 minutes.

[Carnero]

VAR will kill the match experience for fans.

Bin it before it's too late FFS.

[SaintRam]

Just now, philmycock said:

Arms don't count for offside it's body, isn't it?????

I thought it was just furthest forward part of a player, could be wrong.

[Sparkle]

2 minutes ago, RamsFan10 said:

That’s just a picture showing the fact he is offside

Looks like both arms are level to me 

[Andicis]

Unfortunate that the goal was ruled out, but correct decision ,Waghorn's foot was off.

So far, this game has been a reasonable summary of our season. We've played pretty football in patches, but we've given the ball away several times at the back, been slightly sloppy and not created too much. We had one lovely move where Mount skied, but it would have been our goal of the season if it came off, the build up play was beautiful.

I hope we can keep this up in the second half, but create more, because in the final third we're definitely lacking.

[LB_DCFC]

2 minutes ago, philmycock said:

Arms don't count for offside it's body, isn't it?????

shoulders definitely do, and that looks bloody tight

[Millenniumram]

Frustrating but we’re well in this. Shocking first half hour, then excellent and controlled last 15. Play like the last 15 for the rest of the game and we’ll win.

[ck-]

The number 4's chest looks like it's level with Waghorn's boot.

[Gritstone Ram]

1 minute ago, SaintRam said:

Look closer. The arm you can see is actually the Saints defender. It extends beyond Waghorn's

His hand does and his shoulder is level with Waghorns foot.

[Pottig]

Ridiculous decision that took far too long for the officials to arrive at. 

[cstand]

Anybody who thinks that is offside needs to go to specsavers. 

[Sith Happens]

1 minute ago, LB_DCFC said:

no, but shoulders do, and that looks bloody tight

Yup. Onside possibly. Hard to tell but ref clearly inept and had ignored the shoulder.

 

[Norman]

So the line has beem drawn on the wrong place. Great.

[Ruud Aralliss]

Bit concerned about how central Malone is when they break, leaving their winger acres of space

[JoetheRam]

Blimey. Even Shearer is on our side.

[SaintRam]

Lineker clarified the rule, arms dont count. I think I'm still supported in it being onside though. 

[bigbadbob]

5 minutes ago, Ellafella said:

Really?!!!!??? 

Really!

[Curtains]

3 minutes ago, RamsFan10 said:

That’s just a picture showing the fact he is offside

might be controversial but it took 2 minutes to get the right decision, if it was against us we wouldn’t mind. 

It has to be a part of the body you can use so arm is NA but shoulder is 

Onside.

Diabolical decision 

[Derbados]

Vestegards shoulder level with Waghorns foot, not offside. Infuriating officiating 

[Sparkle]

You can score of any part of your body including your hand if the ball deflects in so long as it isn’t deliberate handball