Jump to content

gfs1ram

Member
  • Posts

    583
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by gfs1ram

  1. 12 hours ago, Ellafella said:

     

    1Wildsmith                    7    Did nothing wrong. couple of good saves.

    12Smith                        5     not his recent self. arguing with NML a lot first half

    3Forsyth                      7.5     just MoM on basis of fewer mistakes 

    6Cashin                       3     Just very poor. Worst he has played.

    15Roberts                   3     Again very poor, nothing like his last few games

    17 Sibley                     6    A few wayward crosses but at least got forward. Hit crossbar.

     38Knight                   5    Maybe early booking effected his game. Not usual self.

    4Hourihane                6   Steady when most around him were falling apart

    11Mendez-Laing       5   Not much joy against his fullback. Lucky not to be subbed.

    10McGoldrick           6   Seemed to be trying too hard but still our most likeliest scorer.

    18Dobbin                  5  Showed good pace at times bit unlucky to be subbed.

    7Barkhuizen             5  Should have scored and super cross for Didzy 'goal'

    9Collins                    6  Thought he was ok in a poor first half, without threatening to score (as usual)

    23White                   6  Added some composure to midfield.

    What an awful match to watch. Thought Lincoln did a good job on Derby first half by closing us down. Far too many not 'on song'. Slow build up , poor passing. Lincoln a yard quicker to the ball. Never seen Cashin play so poorly, concerning, didn't think he had that in him. West Stand Linesman shockingly bad. Still should have won it second half. Not Warne's best tactical match.  We move on.

     

     

  2. 26 minutes ago, ram59 said:

    More recently, Jude Bellingham waited until his 17th birthday, signed professional terms with blues, who sold him next day for £25m. If only Gordon and Delap had done that with us, we'd probably not be in the position we are now.

    Yes and that is after the EFL trying to force them to sell him for £5m - 'in accordance with the EFL business plan' imposed on Brum.

    Think the EFL even charged Brum with breaking the terms of the plan !!!  (Eventually sanity prevailed and no penalty applied - I think)

  3. Thought we were OK for the first 60 minutes. Quite lively. Thought Bird and Smith were very good first half and Dobbin was more effective. Just needed a little more incisiveness.The two Sheffield subs up front improved things for them and they had the better of the last 20 minutes helped with the Officials rapidly going down the pan and favouring them completely.

    Thought our defence was excellent second half with Forsyth outstanding.

    Not the best game but certainly far from the worst imo.

     

  4. Wildsmith                    5   Nothing to do but kicking was poor.

    Smith                           6

    Cashin                         4  Cost us the game.

    Forsyth                        6

    Robert’s                       6

    Mendez-Laing            5  Should have been the match winner but under used and pitch did not help.

    Spearman                   5

    Sibley                          5  Scared to make a challenge after his 'lucky' yellow card.

    Hourihane                   4  Back to normal - no influence.

    Bird                              6  Good assist. 

    Dobbin                         4  Disappointing. Should have scored at least 1. Should have been subbed imo.

    Osula                           6.5  Two good goals. Our only outlet with pace. Should not have been subbed.

    Thompson                   5

    Collins                          4  Disappointing. Not effective out on the wing needed to be central.

    Sending off and penalty changed the game but really we were poor throughout. Should have been out of sight by half time.

     

  5. 4 minutes ago, jimbo jones said:

    What’s Graeme Shinnie doing these days? 

    Good question. He is definitely the type of player you need in this league.

    Bird, Knight & Hourihane are all good players but in my opinion better suited to the Championship and above. That's not to say they are too good for League 1 but if given time they can all dictate and control matches. It's becoming pretty obvious that you don't get that time in League 1.

    I noticed on Saturday within 30 seconds of the start Knight was being manhandled on the halfway line and he was nowhere near the ball. The look on his face at the PV players physicality said it all.

    Smith and Rooney may fare better which leads me to think we could see Knight or/and Bird sold in January. That's on the assumption that if we did sell them we would be able to reinvest the proceeds in 'Warne' type players.

     

  6. Derby born (Nightingale, a popular place !!?)

    My Dad took me to my first match at the BBG in January 1959 - see picture below that still hangs in Pride Park. I was somewhere on that picture on the Popside. PNE in a FA Cup match 2-2.     2 or 3 inches of snow on the pitch and on the terraces. The match would not have been played now a day.

    DERBY PLAYED IN RED !!!! ? and I see both teams had white shorts.

    'Forever Derby' from that day onwards even though I have lived 50 miles away since 1967.

    Two daughters both keen Rams fans and season ticket holders. Although the eldest had a brief skirmish with Coventry the year they won the Cup but I soon put a stop to that !!!

    We still travel the 100 mile round trip.        IT'S IN YOR DNA.

     

     

    C6148657-1942-474E-AEF2-B28D6EB3CB86.jpg

  7. Wildsmith         7.5    3 or 4 excellent saves

    Chester            6   Very steady for first game back. Should have used M-L more as an outlet in last 10 mins.

    Knight              6    Usual energetic game

    Roberts            6    Steady

    Cashin              6    Steady as usual

    Davies               5.5  Not yet fully match fit

    McGoldrick       7   Did well, lively could/ should have scored a couple.

    Sibley                6.5  Lively

    Hourihane         6  Apart from scoring the two goals had a very poor game.

    Mendez-Laing  7   Very lively when he came on. caused panic down the right hand side. Under used.

    Bird ?              5   Tried hard but struggling at the moment

    Collins                6  Did OK when he came on.

    Barkhuizen         6.5   Lively. 

    Forsyth               6   

    Substitutions had a real effect on this game - well done Rosey.

  8. 2 hours ago, Ellafella said:

    Wildsmith              6  Brilliant one handed save at 0-0

    Knight                    6  Energetic as ever brilliant block on the line.

    Forsyth                  6  You could see the tactics initially against their small full back

     Cashin                  6  Would probably have been my MoM had it not been for his costly error for 3rd goal.

    Stearman              6  Steady but exposed by lack of a mid-field

    Dobbin                  5  too late to have an impact

    McGoldrick           6.5  Lively and a good assist for the first goal.

    Sibley                    5  Had lilltle impact. Out of position.

    Hourihane            4  Very disappointing game. Involved but too unforced many errors

    Mendez-Laing     6  Excellent individual goal. Our main threat.

    Bird ?                 4  Another disappointing game. Overwhelmed in mid-field. 

    Collins                  6  Took his goal well. Probably the main positive from the game. Again little support.

    Barkhuizen          5  Got clattered quite a bit. Little influence.

    Thompson           3  Could see the logic of bolstering the poor mid-field but a bit of a headless chicken performance. No impact.                                                   

    Osula                   5  Put himself about. Unfair to judge yet with little support. Think a more experienced loanee is what we wanted.

    At half time I said 2-0 and we have not played. Totally 'out passed' and over ran in mid-field. No support to front men. Disappointing. Substitutes had adverse effect and with hindsight (how wonderful that is !!) Rooney's introduction may have been more beneficial. Reverting to a back 3 with either Fozzy or Rooney in there may have helped following the introduction of their substitutes.

    Food for thought !

     

  9. Wildsmith                     6

    Knight                           9

    Forsyth                         7

    Roberts                        6

    Korey Smith                 6 

     Cashin                         6

    Stearman                     7

    Dobbin                         6

    McGoldrick                  8

    Sibley                           7

    Hourihane                    7

    Bird ?                        6

    Collins                          6

    Barkhuizen                   7

  10. It has to be 13th September 1969. Before segregation. I can remember the situation like yesterday.

    Newcastle 0 Derby 1. McFarland with a majestic header. Our first season back in the 'old' First Division.

    I travel up to St James Park on the Ramaway train with my friend Robin Morris (where are you now Robin??)

    Got into the ground with black and white everywhere. It wasn't until McFarland scored and the two of us were going crazy that we realised all the black and white around us were Newcastle fans and the Newkie Brown in most pockets became prominent!!

    Decided to stop our celebrations and somewhat cowardly blend back into the crowd keeping a low profile for the rest of the game.

    If I remember correctly Derby went to the top of the league that day and it was 10 games unbeaten on our return to the 'big' time.

    A great train ride home was had by all.

    It was also a week before the famous 5-0 Tottenham game.

    Great memories.

×
×
  • Create New...