Jump to content

Ghost of Clough

Member
  • Posts

    18,761
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Reputation Activity

  1. Like
    Ghost of Clough got a reaction from 48 hours in New signings, who will be first...and next?   
    I haven't exactly followed the careers of our new signings, so can't tell if Transfermarkt has accurately recorded their injuries or not, but here's a list of the total number of games our new signings have missed due to injury... in their career...
    Chester - 58
    McGoldrick - 21
    Mendez-Laing - 12
    Smith - 9
    Barkhuizen - 0
    Collins - 0
    Hourihane - 2
    Loach - 0
    Oduroh - 0
    Roberts - 0
    Wildsmith - 0
    The two at the top of that list have played over 800 club games between them. For them to have only missed 10% of game due to injury isn't what I would call having "bad injury records". Even then, we have players in the squad who can fill in, never mind who the 4 players coming will play.
    McGoldrick (CF) - Collins has a remarkable record on the injury front and can be relied upon to be available all season as CF. We also have Stretton and Barkuizen who could cover.
    McGoldrick (AM/SS) - Sibley, Knight, Hourihane
    Chester (CB) - Between Davies, Stearman, Cashin, Roberts, Forsyth and Bielik, we'll have enough cover at CB even if we have an injury crisis of monumental proportions.
  2. Haha
    Ghost of Clough reacted to Chester40 in New signings, who will be first...and next?   
    I'd trust him to get the most tasteful yet not over priced room too.
  3. Angry
    Ghost of Clough reacted to i-Ram in New signings, who will be first...and next?   
    Get a room.
  4. Clap
    Ghost of Clough got a reaction from FlyBritishMidland in New signings, who will be first...and next?   
    The same Sheffield Wednesday who have an older squad than us? 

    Of course, this very crude average doesn't account for players who will actually play. For example, game time for the likes of Stearman and Loach will be minimal.
    Wycombe, Sheffield Wednesday and Wigan (despite you claiming they had a young squad) regularly fielded the oldest starting 11s in the league last season. Wycombe actually fielded 46 of the top 60 oldest 11s last season. Those three clubs finished 1st, 4th and 6th, so there is some merit to having a lot of experience in L1.
     
    You're making your judgement entirely on what you've read online, which has no regard to our situation and the players we're capable of recruiting whilst under a business plan (no transfer fees). It also takes a selective approach, looking at only young squads, rather than the other end of the scale. Wigan have consistently had one of the oldest squads during their time in L1, whilst Rotherham are always at the top end of the age table too.
  5. Clap
    Ghost of Clough got a reaction from Dordogne-Ram in New signings, who will be first...and next?   
    I haven't exactly followed the careers of our new signings, so can't tell if Transfermarkt has accurately recorded their injuries or not, but here's a list of the total number of games our new signings have missed due to injury... in their career...
    Chester - 58
    McGoldrick - 21
    Mendez-Laing - 12
    Smith - 9
    Barkhuizen - 0
    Collins - 0
    Hourihane - 2
    Loach - 0
    Oduroh - 0
    Roberts - 0
    Wildsmith - 0
    The two at the top of that list have played over 800 club games between them. For them to have only missed 10% of game due to injury isn't what I would call having "bad injury records". Even then, we have players in the squad who can fill in, never mind who the 4 players coming will play.
    McGoldrick (CF) - Collins has a remarkable record on the injury front and can be relied upon to be available all season as CF. We also have Stretton and Barkuizen who could cover.
    McGoldrick (AM/SS) - Sibley, Knight, Hourihane
    Chester (CB) - Between Davies, Stearman, Cashin, Roberts, Forsyth and Bielik, we'll have enough cover at CB even if we have an injury crisis of monumental proportions.
  6. Like
    Ghost of Clough got a reaction from Ramarena in New signings, who will be first...and next?   
    The same Sheffield Wednesday who have an older squad than us? 

    Of course, this very crude average doesn't account for players who will actually play. For example, game time for the likes of Stearman and Loach will be minimal.
    Wycombe, Sheffield Wednesday and Wigan (despite you claiming they had a young squad) regularly fielded the oldest starting 11s in the league last season. Wycombe actually fielded 46 of the top 60 oldest 11s last season. Those three clubs finished 1st, 4th and 6th, so there is some merit to having a lot of experience in L1.
     
    You're making your judgement entirely on what you've read online, which has no regard to our situation and the players we're capable of recruiting whilst under a business plan (no transfer fees). It also takes a selective approach, looking at only young squads, rather than the other end of the scale. Wigan have consistently had one of the oldest squads during their time in L1, whilst Rotherham are always at the top end of the age table too.
  7. Clap
    Ghost of Clough reacted to ram59 in New signings, who will be first...and next?   
    Unfortunately, it appears that we are not in a position to acquire the ideal players, which are young talented players with potential in the lower leagues. These players will command a fee, even those at non League clubs will cost something.
    Our signings can only fall into 3 categories, experienced free agents towards the end of their careers, younger players who have been deemed to be failures and up and coming young loanees from premier/championship clubs.
  8. Cheers
    Ghost of Clough reacted to Chester40 in New signings, who will be first...and next?   
    'Enjoyed' all your posting about the financial stuff for the last 18months..and previously your academy insights. Its  really good to see your other posting is every bit as informed. Best poster on here, talk lots of (non knee-jerk) sense.
  9. Like
    Ghost of Clough got a reaction from Premier ram in New style and tactics ?   
    Bonucci and Chielini had great success at Euro 2020.
    Davies and Jagielka was working very well fit us last season.
  10. Like
    Ghost of Clough got a reaction from Carl Sagan in New signings, who will be first...and next?   
    @Oldben you keep driving this agenda against this suthis's recruitment. There are three main factors to consider.
    1. We had 3 and a bit weeks to get players signed up
    2. We can't pay any fees
    3. We can only offer 2 year deals at most.
    These factors meant we were limited to free agents, who are typically over 30, injury prone, or very young and judged to not be good enough by their former club. Players younger than 30 are going to be looking for more than just 2 years, so cuts the options down further.
    We still have 8 players aged 21 or below in our squad, amd likely to add a couple more in that age band before the window closes. We've signed experienced players for those 8 to learn off. We haven't had many 'streetwise' players in recent seasons, but now we have a lot - this cannot be understated in both developing our younger players and performances on the pitch.
  11. Clap
    Ghost of Clough got a reaction from RoyMac5 in New signings, who will be first...and next?   
    @Oldben you keep driving this agenda against this suthis's recruitment. There are three main factors to consider.
    1. We had 3 and a bit weeks to get players signed up
    2. We can't pay any fees
    3. We can only offer 2 year deals at most.
    These factors meant we were limited to free agents, who are typically over 30, injury prone, or very young and judged to not be good enough by their former club. Players younger than 30 are going to be looking for more than just 2 years, so cuts the options down further.
    We still have 8 players aged 21 or below in our squad, amd likely to add a couple more in that age band before the window closes. We've signed experienced players for those 8 to learn off. We haven't had many 'streetwise' players in recent seasons, but now we have a lot - this cannot be understated in both developing our younger players and performances on the pitch.
  12. Clap
    Ghost of Clough got a reaction from Ramarena in New signings, who will be first...and next?   
    @Oldben you keep driving this agenda against this suthis's recruitment. There are three main factors to consider.
    1. We had 3 and a bit weeks to get players signed up
    2. We can't pay any fees
    3. We can only offer 2 year deals at most.
    These factors meant we were limited to free agents, who are typically over 30, injury prone, or very young and judged to not be good enough by their former club. Players younger than 30 are going to be looking for more than just 2 years, so cuts the options down further.
    We still have 8 players aged 21 or below in our squad, amd likely to add a couple more in that age band before the window closes. We've signed experienced players for those 8 to learn off. We haven't had many 'streetwise' players in recent seasons, but now we have a lot - this cannot be understated in both developing our younger players and performances on the pitch.
  13. Clap
    Ghost of Clough got a reaction from Caerphilly Ram in New signings, who will be first...and next?   
    @Oldben you keep driving this agenda against this suthis's recruitment. There are three main factors to consider.
    1. We had 3 and a bit weeks to get players signed up
    2. We can't pay any fees
    3. We can only offer 2 year deals at most.
    These factors meant we were limited to free agents, who are typically over 30, injury prone, or very young and judged to not be good enough by their former club. Players younger than 30 are going to be looking for more than just 2 years, so cuts the options down further.
    We still have 8 players aged 21 or below in our squad, amd likely to add a couple more in that age band before the window closes. We've signed experienced players for those 8 to learn off. We haven't had many 'streetwise' players in recent seasons, but now we have a lot - this cannot be understated in both developing our younger players and performances on the pitch.
  14. Clap
    Ghost of Clough got a reaction from LeedsCityRam in New signings, who will be first...and next?   
    @Oldben you keep driving this agenda against this suthis's recruitment. There are three main factors to consider.
    1. We had 3 and a bit weeks to get players signed up
    2. We can't pay any fees
    3. We can only offer 2 year deals at most.
    These factors meant we were limited to free agents, who are typically over 30, injury prone, or very young and judged to not be good enough by their former club. Players younger than 30 are going to be looking for more than just 2 years, so cuts the options down further.
    We still have 8 players aged 21 or below in our squad, amd likely to add a couple more in that age band before the window closes. We've signed experienced players for those 8 to learn off. We haven't had many 'streetwise' players in recent seasons, but now we have a lot - this cannot be understated in both developing our younger players and performances on the pitch.
  15. Like
    Ghost of Clough got a reaction from Carnero in New signings, who will be first...and next?   
    @Oldben you keep driving this agenda against this suthis's recruitment. There are three main factors to consider.
    1. We had 3 and a bit weeks to get players signed up
    2. We can't pay any fees
    3. We can only offer 2 year deals at most.
    These factors meant we were limited to free agents, who are typically over 30, injury prone, or very young and judged to not be good enough by their former club. Players younger than 30 are going to be looking for more than just 2 years, so cuts the options down further.
    We still have 8 players aged 21 or below in our squad, amd likely to add a couple more in that age band before the window closes. We've signed experienced players for those 8 to learn off. We haven't had many 'streetwise' players in recent seasons, but now we have a lot - this cannot be understated in both developing our younger players and performances on the pitch.
  16. Clap
    Ghost of Clough got a reaction from RamDotFi in New signings, who will be first...and next?   
    @Oldben you keep driving this agenda against this suthis's recruitment. There are three main factors to consider.
    1. We had 3 and a bit weeks to get players signed up
    2. We can't pay any fees
    3. We can only offer 2 year deals at most.
    These factors meant we were limited to free agents, who are typically over 30, injury prone, or very young and judged to not be good enough by their former club. Players younger than 30 are going to be looking for more than just 2 years, so cuts the options down further.
    We still have 8 players aged 21 or below in our squad, amd likely to add a couple more in that age band before the window closes. We've signed experienced players for those 8 to learn off. We haven't had many 'streetwise' players in recent seasons, but now we have a lot - this cannot be understated in both developing our younger players and performances on the pitch.
  17. Like
    Ghost of Clough got a reaction from Hans Datdo-Dishes in New signings, who will be first...and next?   
    @Oldben you keep driving this agenda against this suthis's recruitment. There are three main factors to consider.
    1. We had 3 and a bit weeks to get players signed up
    2. We can't pay any fees
    3. We can only offer 2 year deals at most.
    These factors meant we were limited to free agents, who are typically over 30, injury prone, or very young and judged to not be good enough by their former club. Players younger than 30 are going to be looking for more than just 2 years, so cuts the options down further.
    We still have 8 players aged 21 or below in our squad, amd likely to add a couple more in that age band before the window closes. We've signed experienced players for those 8 to learn off. We haven't had many 'streetwise' players in recent seasons, but now we have a lot - this cannot be understated in both developing our younger players and performances on the pitch.
  18. Clap
    Ghost of Clough got a reaction from EnigmaRam in New signings, who will be first...and next?   
    @Oldben you keep driving this agenda against this suthis's recruitment. There are three main factors to consider.
    1. We had 3 and a bit weeks to get players signed up
    2. We can't pay any fees
    3. We can only offer 2 year deals at most.
    These factors meant we were limited to free agents, who are typically over 30, injury prone, or very young and judged to not be good enough by their former club. Players younger than 30 are going to be looking for more than just 2 years, so cuts the options down further.
    We still have 8 players aged 21 or below in our squad, amd likely to add a couple more in that age band before the window closes. We've signed experienced players for those 8 to learn off. We haven't had many 'streetwise' players in recent seasons, but now we have a lot - this cannot be understated in both developing our younger players and performances on the pitch.
  19. Like
    Ghost of Clough got a reaction from angieram in New signings, who will be first...and next?   
    @Oldben you keep driving this agenda against this suthis's recruitment. There are three main factors to consider.
    1. We had 3 and a bit weeks to get players signed up
    2. We can't pay any fees
    3. We can only offer 2 year deals at most.
    These factors meant we were limited to free agents, who are typically over 30, injury prone, or very young and judged to not be good enough by their former club. Players younger than 30 are going to be looking for more than just 2 years, so cuts the options down further.
    We still have 8 players aged 21 or below in our squad, amd likely to add a couple more in that age band before the window closes. We've signed experienced players for those 8 to learn off. We haven't had many 'streetwise' players in recent seasons, but now we have a lot - this cannot be understated in both developing our younger players and performances on the pitch.
  20. Clap
    Ghost of Clough got a reaction from Ram@Lincoln in New signings, who will be first...and next?   
    @Oldben you keep driving this agenda against this suthis's recruitment. There are three main factors to consider.
    1. We had 3 and a bit weeks to get players signed up
    2. We can't pay any fees
    3. We can only offer 2 year deals at most.
    These factors meant we were limited to free agents, who are typically over 30, injury prone, or very young and judged to not be good enough by their former club. Players younger than 30 are going to be looking for more than just 2 years, so cuts the options down further.
    We still have 8 players aged 21 or below in our squad, amd likely to add a couple more in that age band before the window closes. We've signed experienced players for those 8 to learn off. We haven't had many 'streetwise' players in recent seasons, but now we have a lot - this cannot be understated in both developing our younger players and performances on the pitch.
  21. Clap
    Ghost of Clough got a reaction from Reggie Greenwood in New signings, who will be first...and next?   
    @Oldben you keep driving this agenda against this suthis's recruitment. There are three main factors to consider.
    1. We had 3 and a bit weeks to get players signed up
    2. We can't pay any fees
    3. We can only offer 2 year deals at most.
    These factors meant we were limited to free agents, who are typically over 30, injury prone, or very young and judged to not be good enough by their former club. Players younger than 30 are going to be looking for more than just 2 years, so cuts the options down further.
    We still have 8 players aged 21 or below in our squad, amd likely to add a couple more in that age band before the window closes. We've signed experienced players for those 8 to learn off. We haven't had many 'streetwise' players in recent seasons, but now we have a lot - this cannot be understated in both developing our younger players and performances on the pitch.
  22. Like
    Ghost of Clough got a reaction from Rev in New signings, who will be first...and next?   
    @Oldben you keep driving this agenda against this suthis's recruitment. There are three main factors to consider.
    1. We had 3 and a bit weeks to get players signed up
    2. We can't pay any fees
    3. We can only offer 2 year deals at most.
    These factors meant we were limited to free agents, who are typically over 30, injury prone, or very young and judged to not be good enough by their former club. Players younger than 30 are going to be looking for more than just 2 years, so cuts the options down further.
    We still have 8 players aged 21 or below in our squad, amd likely to add a couple more in that age band before the window closes. We've signed experienced players for those 8 to learn off. We haven't had many 'streetwise' players in recent seasons, but now we have a lot - this cannot be understated in both developing our younger players and performances on the pitch.
  23. Like
    Ghost of Clough got a reaction from LeedsCityRam in Match Thread: Rams vs Leicester (Pride Park, today 1pm)   
    Nice to see 2 players closing the keeper down to force the mistake.

  24. Clap
    Ghost of Clough got a reaction from Rample in Craig Forsyth - Signed one year contract   
    No
    Also no
  25. Clap
    Ghost of Clough got a reaction from DCFC1388 in Craig Forsyth - Signed one year contract   
    No
    Also no
×
×
  • Create New...