Jump to content

Ghost of Clough

Member
  • Posts

    19,602
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Reputation Activity

  1. Clap
    Ghost of Clough reacted to Caerphilly Ram in Derby v Shrewsbury (A) Match Thread   
    My guess is a 4-2-3-1;
                       Wildsmith
    Nyambe.  Nelson.  Cashin.  Forsyth
                   Fornah     Smith
         Sibley          Bird        Barkhuizen 
                           Collins
  2. Clap
    Ghost of Clough got a reaction from DavesaRam in How good is our squad?   
    How many people are saying "we're a shoe in for promotion"? Very few.
    There are two main streams of displeasure.
    1. Style of play often resulting in an inability to pass the ball to a team mate
    2. League position being some way off challenging for automatic promotion. We're only 11 games in, but already 9 points off 2nd spot. Many would argue this isn't challenging for automatics.
    One man is ultimately responsible for the first topic. He's the one who coaches the team and instructs them how to play on matchday. That criticism is therefore perfectly valid if those supporters do not enjoy the football on display.
    When comparing a side to determine if they're overperforming or underperforming, budget vs league position is one of the main metrics. When looking at historic wage expenditure of clubs in this division, rumoured fees paid for players in the summer, etc.. it's very obvious that we have a 'top 3' budget. Since we're currently 9th in the table (7th on ppg), we're underperforming. People may disagree over the reason, but it still ultimately falls back on Warne.
    - Some say Warne isn't getting the most out of this squad due to tactics, player selection, etc... = Warne at fault
    - You say the players aren't good enough. Therefore, either of the following are the reason:
          - The recruitment team, which Warne helped to assemble, isn't identifying good enough players
          - Warne didn't choose the right players in the summer window
          - Warne couldn't convince the right players to join
  3. Clap
    Ghost of Clough got a reaction from MickD in Derby v Shrewsbury (A) Match Thread   
    Good point. I expect Warne will start with Barkhuizen and Sibley on the wings. Mendez-Laing probably won't even be in the squad, with Ward taking the spare spot on the bench. Something like this:
    Wildsmith
    Nyambe   Nelson   Cashin   Forsyth
    Fornah   Smith
    Barkhuizen   Bird   Sibley
    Collins
    Subs: Vickers, Bradley, Wilson, Ward, Hourihane, Washington, Waghorn
  4. Like
    Ghost of Clough got a reaction from Jubbs in Derby v Shrewsbury (A) Match Thread   
    Due to the weather and potential state of the pitch, I'm mentally preparing myself for the ball spending a lot of time in the air tomorrow. I couldn't think of many worse conditions to face Shrewsbury away, so it'll be a tough match.
  5. Haha
    Ghost of Clough reacted to JuanFloEvraTheCocu'sNesta in Derby v Shrewsbury (A) Match Thread   
    True, I'm sure if the weather was better we'd be rolling it around like Guardiola's Barcelona.
  6. Clap
    Ghost of Clough got a reaction from Marriot Ram99 in What are your long term realistic ambitions for DCFC?   
    What you've just described sounds a lot like Crystal Palace. It doesn't sound too difficult to "be like Crystal Palace".
  7. Haha
    Ghost of Clough reacted to Blondest Goat in How good is our squad?   
    Where do you go for your arguements on the days that you don't come on here?
  8. Clap
    Ghost of Clough got a reaction from The Scarlet Pimpernel in How good is our squad?   
    There's a very obvious trend in every division between wage budget and league position. Just because Man Utd spend the most on wages doesn't mean they deserve to win the league, just like any side doesn't deserve to win a game just by turning up.
    Given Man Utd are spending the most but still not winning anything, you identify the waste. Is the manager underperforming, or is the club wasting money on players? I see Maguire ans Sancho as two obvious examples of massive wages and little game time. Shaw, Martial, Reguilon are on a decent wedge and not playing much either.
    Same will apply to us. We are currently underperforming against budget. Have we given our players more money than their ability deserves, do they need more time to settle in and adjust tonthe tactics, or is the manager not good enough? 
  9. Haha
    Ghost of Clough reacted to Tamworthram in FA Cup 1st Round Draw.   
    That’s the second time today I’ve seen that phrase misquoted on this forum to sound more painful. 😀
    It’s “bat an eyelid” not “batter an eyelid” unless you live in Glasgow and have run out of mars bars.
  10. Haha
    Ghost of Clough reacted to richinspain in Championship 23/24   
    I imagine he is a free agent. There's still time!
  11. Clap
    Ghost of Clough got a reaction from RoyMac5 in How good is our squad?   
    Do you want me to post screenshots for all of the spreadsheets I've used regarding the club's finances over the past 2 decades and explain everything line by line?
    There's also the information we've been told regarding the business plan, turnover exceeding what had been budgeted for, League 1 restrictions, etc..
    My knowledge of football finance also results a conservative calculated estimate for our turnover to be £16m, whilst a realistic estimate for this season is £18m. You can compare this turnover figure to our historic accounts to give yourself an idea of what a reasonable wages to turnover ratio is.
    Our wage bill in 12/13 was £12.1m, which was our lowest since relegation from the PL (our turnover was also at its lowest, £15.4m.
    Our wages were also at just £9.4m in 05/06 (turnover was £11.4m), the lowest it has been since 96/97.
    In summary, the historical data for our club and others as well as basic information provided to us give me great confidence in a £10m figure being a lower end estimate for our wage bill.
  12. Like
    Ghost of Clough got a reaction from sage in How good is our squad?   
    In most cases, the most recent accounts for clubs in this division are a useful indication of current budget.
    There is a lack of financial information available regarding Port Vale, Leyton Orient, Cambridge, Cheltenham, Wycombe, Northampton and Stevenage. However, it it very reasonable to make the assumption that these "small companies" also have smaller wage bills than ours.
    Whilst there is limited data for Bristol Rovers and Oxford, the data which is available would suggest an absolute maximum wage bill of £9.2m and 7.7m respectively. It seems fairly obvious that Oxford have pushed the boat out a bit this summer, and will likely be around the £9-10m mark.
    Reading were put under a £16m wage cap for last season in the Championship. With a significant drop in revenue and an owner seemingly unwilling to put more money in the club, anything higher than £8m seems unlikely.
    Wigan had a £13m wage bill when promoted last time, but are reportedly under tighter control this time.
    That brings us on to the rest, who have all disclosed their wage bill in the most recent accounts.
    Charlton - £10.6m
    Bolton - £10.2m
    Barnsley - £8.1m
    Portsmouth - £7.9m
    Blackpool - £7.7m
    Peterborough - £7m
    Fleetwood - £6.2m
    Lincoln - £6.2m
    Burton - £5.1m
    Shrewsbury - £4.4m
    Exeter - £4m
    Carlisle - £3.4m
    My "top 3" budget claim is therefore very valid since a conservative estimate would put us at £10m.
  13. Clap
    Ghost of Clough got a reaction from Chester40 in Derby v Shrewsbury (A) Match Thread   
    I'm certain he'll start, but most likely on the wing. It's hard to see Warne breaking up the Fornah, Smith, Bird midfield at the moment.
  14. Clap
    Ghost of Clough got a reaction from jimtastic56 in FA Cup 1st Round Draw.   
    TV companies want to have as many viewers as possible, so they don't just look at local support. Thanks to Ryan Reynolds, Wrexham are now known nationally and globally. For example, Derby currnetly have just shy of 400k Twitter followers, whilst Wrexham have exploded to over 550k.
  15. Haha
    Ghost of Clough reacted to Gee SCREAMER !! in FA Cup 1st Round Draw.   
    Niall Horan needs to start shifting his arse and plugging us a bit more for those free shirts he gets every year.
  16. Like
    Ghost of Clough got a reaction from Tamworthram in FA Cup 1st Round Draw.   
    TV companies want to have as many viewers as possible, so they don't just look at local support. Thanks to Ryan Reynolds, Wrexham are now known nationally and globally. For example, Derby currnetly have just shy of 400k Twitter followers, whilst Wrexham have exploded to over 550k.
  17. Haha
    Ghost of Clough reacted to Foreveram in FA Cup 1st Round Draw.   
    I know, I posted it two pages and three days back 😂
  18. Like
    Ghost of Clough got a reaction from Bald Eagle's Barmy Army in Academy thread 23/24   
    There is a lack of intent by the management team to play younger players.
    Thompson was given minimal minutes last season, then Warne was still reluctant to use him this season. When he did, it was at LM.
    Robinson has been in 8 of Warne's matchday squads and only used on the pitch once - during his first month managing the club. The Carlisle game when we were winning 2-0 was the perfect opportunity to bring him on as a late sub.
    Other youngsters have been named in squads, but the intent is never to actually test them. Warne stated he was hoping we would go 3-0 up vs Notts County for us to give them a run out.
  19. Clap
    Ghost of Clough got a reaction from RoyMac5 in Academy thread 23/24   
    There is a gap in the 19-21 age groups, with Bardell the only remaining player from them, and he is currently injured. Delap, Williams and Gordon got poached from those groups, and all would have been in our first team.
    Other notable players from those age groups, who I felt had a chance of making it in our first team being: Solomon, Aghatise, Roberts, Ibrahim and Borkovic. Whilst Roberts and Ibrahim didn't really kick on from when they were 16/17 and their first involvement with the first team, the others suffered from a series of injuries.
    The next age group has already lost Ryan (who I felt was the best CB we've had in the academy in a long time) and Ebiowei (who was already in the first team 2 seasons ago), but we do still have Evans, Richards, and DRobinson.
    From the two age groups below them, we have lost Kellyman, Sharpe, Scanlon and Kaba. Whilst they're all talented and their departures had an impact on the overall quality, none were head and shoulders above the likes of Cox, Hawkins, Davidson, Brown, JThompson, Allen, etc... I woudln't expect any of them to be regulars in the matchday squad yet, but I would expect a handful of minutes throughout the season. If they are named in the squads, then there needs to be an intent to play them, and give them a meaningful amount of time on the pitch, no matter if we're 2-0 down or 2-0 up, and definitely not just for 1 minute to run the clock down.
  20. Clap
    Ghost of Clough got a reaction from RoyMac5 in Academy thread 23/24   
    There is a lack of intent by the management team to play younger players.
    Thompson was given minimal minutes last season, then Warne was still reluctant to use him this season. When he did, it was at LM.
    Robinson has been in 8 of Warne's matchday squads and only used on the pitch once - during his first month managing the club. The Carlisle game when we were winning 2-0 was the perfect opportunity to bring him on as a late sub.
    Other youngsters have been named in squads, but the intent is never to actually test them. Warne stated he was hoping we would go 3-0 up vs Notts County for us to give them a run out.
  21. Like
    Ghost of Clough got a reaction from Jubbs in Academy thread 23/24   
    There is a lack of intent by the management team to play younger players.
    Thompson was given minimal minutes last season, then Warne was still reluctant to use him this season. When he did, it was at LM.
    Robinson has been in 8 of Warne's matchday squads and only used on the pitch once - during his first month managing the club. The Carlisle game when we were winning 2-0 was the perfect opportunity to bring him on as a late sub.
    Other youngsters have been named in squads, but the intent is never to actually test them. Warne stated he was hoping we would go 3-0 up vs Notts County for us to give them a run out.
  22. Clap
    Ghost of Clough got a reaction from TomTom92 in How good is our squad?   
    How many people are saying "we're a shoe in for promotion"? Very few.
    There are two main streams of displeasure.
    1. Style of play often resulting in an inability to pass the ball to a team mate
    2. League position being some way off challenging for automatic promotion. We're only 11 games in, but already 9 points off 2nd spot. Many would argue this isn't challenging for automatics.
    One man is ultimately responsible for the first topic. He's the one who coaches the team and instructs them how to play on matchday. That criticism is therefore perfectly valid if those supporters do not enjoy the football on display.
    When comparing a side to determine if they're overperforming or underperforming, budget vs league position is one of the main metrics. When looking at historic wage expenditure of clubs in this division, rumoured fees paid for players in the summer, etc.. it's very obvious that we have a 'top 3' budget. Since we're currently 9th in the table (7th on ppg), we're underperforming. People may disagree over the reason, but it still ultimately falls back on Warne.
    - Some say Warne isn't getting the most out of this squad due to tactics, player selection, etc... = Warne at fault
    - You say the players aren't good enough. Therefore, either of the following are the reason:
          - The recruitment team, which Warne helped to assemble, isn't identifying good enough players
          - Warne didn't choose the right players in the summer window
          - Warne couldn't convince the right players to join
  23. COYR
    Ghost of Clough reacted to Bald Eagle's Barmy Army in Academy thread 23/24   
    My mates just text me to say the U15s beat Leicester tonight 4-1 in a cup game 😀 ⚽️ 
  24. Clap
    Ghost of Clough got a reaction from NOTSA74 in How good is our squad?   
    How many people are saying "we're a shoe in for promotion"? Very few.
    There are two main streams of displeasure.
    1. Style of play often resulting in an inability to pass the ball to a team mate
    2. League position being some way off challenging for automatic promotion. We're only 11 games in, but already 9 points off 2nd spot. Many would argue this isn't challenging for automatics.
    One man is ultimately responsible for the first topic. He's the one who coaches the team and instructs them how to play on matchday. That criticism is therefore perfectly valid if those supporters do not enjoy the football on display.
    When comparing a side to determine if they're overperforming or underperforming, budget vs league position is one of the main metrics. When looking at historic wage expenditure of clubs in this division, rumoured fees paid for players in the summer, etc.. it's very obvious that we have a 'top 3' budget. Since we're currently 9th in the table (7th on ppg), we're underperforming. People may disagree over the reason, but it still ultimately falls back on Warne.
    - Some say Warne isn't getting the most out of this squad due to tactics, player selection, etc... = Warne at fault
    - You say the players aren't good enough. Therefore, either of the following are the reason:
          - The recruitment team, which Warne helped to assemble, isn't identifying good enough players
          - Warne didn't choose the right players in the summer window
          - Warne couldn't convince the right players to join
  25. Clap
    Ghost of Clough got a reaction from norwichram in How good is our squad?   
    How many people are saying "we're a shoe in for promotion"? Very few.
    There are two main streams of displeasure.
    1. Style of play often resulting in an inability to pass the ball to a team mate
    2. League position being some way off challenging for automatic promotion. We're only 11 games in, but already 9 points off 2nd spot. Many would argue this isn't challenging for automatics.
    One man is ultimately responsible for the first topic. He's the one who coaches the team and instructs them how to play on matchday. That criticism is therefore perfectly valid if those supporters do not enjoy the football on display.
    When comparing a side to determine if they're overperforming or underperforming, budget vs league position is one of the main metrics. When looking at historic wage expenditure of clubs in this division, rumoured fees paid for players in the summer, etc.. it's very obvious that we have a 'top 3' budget. Since we're currently 9th in the table (7th on ppg), we're underperforming. People may disagree over the reason, but it still ultimately falls back on Warne.
    - Some say Warne isn't getting the most out of this squad due to tactics, player selection, etc... = Warne at fault
    - You say the players aren't good enough. Therefore, either of the following are the reason:
          - The recruitment team, which Warne helped to assemble, isn't identifying good enough players
          - Warne didn't choose the right players in the summer window
          - Warne couldn't convince the right players to join
×
×
  • Create New...