Jump to content

Highgate

Member
  • Posts

    2,523
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Reputation Activity

  1. Clap
    Highgate got a reaction from therealhantsram in Eurovision 2024   
    It's not really countries voting for the neighbours though as such....it's migrant populations voting for their home country. Except the Greece-Cyprus thing....   And people in N.Ireland can vote for Ireland. 
    That's why Russia was such a good bet for the win before they were kicked out...they have populations is so many other Eastern European countries.  
  2. COYR
    Highgate reacted to Ian Buxton's Bat in Worst Refereeing decision for and against Derby.   
    100% agree.
    Roger Milford. Last game of his career.
    Nailed on first place......all other dodgy decisions are playing for the runner up spot.
    Still irks 30 years on. Probably the worst day of my life from a footballing perspective.
  3. Like
    Highgate got a reaction from Carl Sagan in Worst Refereeing decision for and against Derby.   
    Best dodgy decision in our favour the penalty against Rotherham in 1986, the most crucial anyway.  
    Worst decision, not to give a foul when Roberts elbowed Taylor in the face in 1994...or course that injustice was compounded by Paul Williams' worst attempted clearance in Derby history one second later. Still hurts.
  4. Like
    Highgate got a reaction from Reggie Greenwood in Worst Refereeing decision for and against Derby.   
    Best dodgy decision in our favour the penalty against Rotherham in 1986, the most crucial anyway.  
    Worst decision, not to give a foul when Roberts elbowed Taylor in the face in 1994...or course that injustice was compounded by Paul Williams' worst attempted clearance in Derby history one second later. Still hurts.
  5. Clap
    Highgate reacted to Reggie Greenwood in Worst Refereeing decision for and against Derby.   
    Jack Taylor 1976 FA Cup Semi final v Manure when Dave Nish chipped the ball over the defence and ran on to score when the game was 1-0 but disallowed for a mystery player who was supposedly interfering with play. 
    Roger Milford in the play off final v Fester not giving a blatant foul on Martin Taylor for their equaliser and letting Steve Walsh and co kick our players all over the park . 
  6. Like
    Highgate reacted to TomTom92 in Premier League the most exciting in the world?   
    No need for Wembley, just whichever team finished higher in the regular season gets home advantage.
  7. Like
    Highgate reacted to TomTom92 in Premier League the most exciting in the world?   
    I can survive without the play offs idea, was just a spur of the moment thought to keep most teams interested and something to play for until the very end. 
    FWIW i'd have the bottom two automatically relegated and then 15th - 18th battling it out for the final drop. But ultimately i don't think the PL would ever trial something like this.
    I'd be intrigued to see how we would reinvigorate the cup competitions. It may be a generational thing but i hold very little feelings towards the cup comps.
  8. Haha
  9. Like
    Highgate reacted to Ramarena in The Ukraine War   
    The senate passes Ukrainian aid with a dupe majority.
    Hopefully the defenders get what they need quickly. Air defence needs to be a huge priority to save Ukrainian civilian lives!
  10. Like
    Highgate reacted to Grimbeard in How is that offside?   
    I agree, chuck it out. And put up with the mistakes, isn't that what living with it means?
  11. Like
    Highgate got a reaction from RadioactiveWaste in How is that offside?   
    Except I don't think we'd live with it, anymore than we lived with referee's mistakes before VAR or we are happy to live with the VAR shambles as it's operating now.  Chuck VAR in the bin.  We tried it, fair enough it was worth an attempt, but it's sucking the life out of the game (I'm in complete agreement with you there) as well as creating nearly as many controversies as it solves. 
  12. Clap
    Highgate reacted to angieram in Supporter of the season   
    Who is DCFC Lee? 
    I personally don't think Clowes should win it. Just not appropriate,  this award is about ordinary fans.
    Clowes deserves all the accolades for what he did (last season, actually) bit in a different arena to this one.
  13. Like
    Highgate got a reaction from TimRam in How is that offside?   
    Except I don't think we'd live with it, anymore than we lived with referee's mistakes before VAR or we are happy to live with the VAR shambles as it's operating now.  Chuck VAR in the bin.  We tried it, fair enough it was worth an attempt, but it's sucking the life out of the game (I'm in complete agreement with you there) as well as creating nearly as many controversies as it solves. 
  14. Like
    Highgate got a reaction from Grimbeard in How is that offside?   
    Yeah you can never be sure if the action has been stopped at precisely the right moment or not.  But if you introduce a margin of error, won't the debate just switch to whether the toenail was within the margin of error line or not, rather than whether it was ahead or behind the last defender?  Whatever criterion is used, whether it's offside by any amount, margin or error or 'clear daylight' between the players, the decision will often come down to judgement calls based on millimetres. 
    I'd be happy to bin VAR altogether and go back to best guess by the officials.  At least then people could go back to celebrating goals naturally when they occur.  
  15. Like
    Highgate reacted to Eddie in Watchable telly   
    Currently watching 'Kin', sort-of a Dublin version of 'Peaky Blinders;.
    Reminds me very much of some of the characters I used to know in Fagan's pub in Drumcondra. It just needs Bertie Ahern to walk in with Bill Clinton (actually happened when I was in the bar) and I would have been transported back to December 2000.
  16. Clap
    Highgate reacted to Alty_Ram in How is that offside?   
    I appreciate that some think VAR is a step in the right direction the above is the argument in a nutshell for me. Is the 'correct by a toenail' forensic approach worth it when it is seemingly so flawed/ambiguous on tight decisions anyway ? The original explanation/justification was that VAR was essentially there to correct big errors and injustices. I'm just not convinced 'drawing lines' on a screen and spending sometimes several minutes making at best dubiously 'accurate' decisions on the tightest of tight calls, is really addressing the problem.

    The crushing of the spontaneity of goal celebrations for frankly impossible to call decisions in a fast moving and highly emotional spectator sport is (IMHO) simply not worth the sacrifice as a spectacle, though I appreciate that many wouldn't agree.
  17. Clap
    Highgate got a reaction from DB83 in How is that offside?   
    Yeah you can never be sure if the action has been stopped at precisely the right moment or not.  But if you introduce a margin of error, won't the debate just switch to whether the toenail was within the margin of error line or not, rather than whether it was ahead or behind the last defender?  Whatever criterion is used, whether it's offside by any amount, margin or error or 'clear daylight' between the players, the decision will often come down to judgement calls based on millimetres. 
    I'd be happy to bin VAR altogether and go back to best guess by the officials.  At least then people could go back to celebrating goals naturally when they occur.  
  18. Clap
    Highgate got a reaction from Reggie Greenwood in How is that offside?   
    Yeah you can never be sure if the action has been stopped at precisely the right moment or not.  But if you introduce a margin of error, won't the debate just switch to whether the toenail was within the margin of error line or not, rather than whether it was ahead or behind the last defender?  Whatever criterion is used, whether it's offside by any amount, margin or error or 'clear daylight' between the players, the decision will often come down to judgement calls based on millimetres. 
    I'd be happy to bin VAR altogether and go back to best guess by the officials.  At least then people could go back to celebrating goals naturally when they occur.  
  19. Clap
    Highgate reacted to Carl Sagan in How is that offside?   
    You're right I'm just shifting the goalposts. As has been said many times, the only way to make VAR work is to have it on the big screen while officials discuss the decision with the fans listening to the conversation. If they're not even prepared to do that, we're much better off ditching it. 
  20. Like
    Highgate got a reaction from Carl Sagan in How is that offside?   
    Yeah you can never be sure if the action has been stopped at precisely the right moment or not.  But if you introduce a margin of error, won't the debate just switch to whether the toenail was within the margin of error line or not, rather than whether it was ahead or behind the last defender?  Whatever criterion is used, whether it's offside by any amount, margin or error or 'clear daylight' between the players, the decision will often come down to judgement calls based on millimetres. 
    I'd be happy to bin VAR altogether and go back to best guess by the officials.  At least then people could go back to celebrating goals naturally when they occur.  
  21. Clap
    Highgate reacted to Loftyhites in How is that offside?   
    I really hope that we get promoted on Saturday but I’m not sure that I want to ever go back to the premier league. Never being able to properly celebrate a goal until all checks are complete is not what football is about (for me, anyway). 
  22. Like
    Highgate got a reaction from Crewton in Palestine   
    I've no idea how much of an issue Iranian oil is for the US these days, but I'm sure the current US president wishes the whole Israel/Gaza/Iran problem wouldn't have exploded like it did in an election year. 
  23. Like
    Highgate got a reaction from Crewton in Palestine   
    Hopefully the damage done isn't too significant, Israel will feel it's proved its point that it can strike Iran whenever and wherever it wishes while Iran won't feel it necessary to launch another retaliatory attack.  That may de-escalate things between the two countries for now.
  24. Clap
    Highgate reacted to Crewton in Palestine   
    Iran have played it down so far, presumably for PR purposes to emphasise to their population and the outside world that Israel can't damage them, so it'll be interesting to see if that's an end to the direct tit-for-tat or not.
    I expect exchanges of attacks between Israel and Iranian proxies will continue unabated.
  25. Clap
    Highgate got a reaction from Leeds Ram in Palestine   
    Yeah, nothing to disagree with here.  Seems perfectly plausible to me that the Iranian regime is trying not to look weak in response to Israeli aggression while at the same time it wants to suppress any dissenting voices regarding it's policies among it's own population.  Those two points don't seem like a contradiction to me. 
    I don't think anyone needs any convincing on how awful the regime in Iran is and how unfortunate Iranians are to have to suffer through it. 
×
×
  • Create New...