Plymouth V Derby County: player Ratings

[Ellafella]

 

Half-marks allowed; please rate all subs. Closes Thursday @ 18:00. Results by Thursday 22:00. Average is 6.00. Therefore, when a sub steps on the pitch he is on 6 - that's the baseline.

1Wildsmith

12Smith

3Forsyth

6Cashin

15Roberts

22Springett

23White

9Collins

4Hourihane

7Sibley

11Mendez-Laing

38Knight

7Barkhuizen

18Dobbin

10McGoldrick

[Guest]

1Wildsmith 6.5 (not sure he was at fault for anything although I did initially feel I could have made a cup of tea while the deflection was going in for the first)

12Smith 6 (not one of his best showings)

3Forsyth 7 (did fine, probably edged MoM for me)

6Cashin 6.5 (has had a very good season on the whole but I wish he'd stop faffing about when there are easier options - has done it  lately noticeably more than he used to)

15Roberts 6 (decent effort)

22Springett 5.5 (don't doubt his effort but disappointing that he's meant to be a good crosser and wasted a good opportunity by crossing it too high and straight out of play from a good position)

23White 6 (good first half, not so good second half. Unlucky with the penalty-that-shouldn't-have-been but a bit naive to flick out his foot - which the attacker was anticipating - when we had plenty of cover and there was no great threat)

9Collins 5.5 (not much time, no impact. These sub cameos are making him look worse than he is)

4Hourihane 5.5 (tidy, but out-manoeuvred, especially in the second half, by a good Plymouth midfield)

7Sibley 5.5 (forgot he even came on)

11Mendez-Laing 6.5 (bonus for finishing off the goal after he nearly didn't; otherwise didn't do enough)

38Knight 6 (you could see the effort but couldn't make a big enough impact)

7Barkhuizen 5.5 (not enough from him, and should have done more with that header)

18Dobbin 5.5 (lively but couldn't cause them problems)

10McGoldrick 6 (brilliant assist but frustrating when (not) doing the simple things, as was often the case)

[bcnram]

1Wildsmith  6

12Smith  6

3Forsyth  6

6Cashin 6

15Roberts  6

22Springett  5

23White  6

9Collins  5

4Hourihane  7

7Sibley  7

11Mendez-Laing  6

38Knight  6

7Barkhuizen  5

18Dobbin  5

10McGoldrick  7

[sage]

1 hour ago, Ellafella said:

 

Half-marks allowed; please rate all subs. Closes Thursday @ 18:00. Results by Thursday 22:00. Average is 6.00. Therefore, when a sub steps on the pitch he is on 6 - that's the baseline.

1Wildsmith 6.5

12Smith 6

3Forsyth 7

6Cashin 6

15Roberts 6

22Springett 5

23White 5.5

9Collins 5.5

4Hourihane 6.5

7Sibley 5.5

11Mendez-Laing 6.5

38Knight 6

7Barkhuizen 6

18Dobbin 5.5

10McGoldrick 6.5

 

[Anag Ram]

1Wildsmith 6.5

12Smith 5.5

3Forsyth 7

6Cashin 6.5

15Roberts 7

22Springett 6

23White 5

9Collins 4

4Hourihane 6.5

7Sibley 5.5

11Mendez-Laing 6

38Knight 6

7Barkhuizen 5.5

18Dobbin 5.5

10McGoldrick 5.5

Was at the game. We lost midfield and let Plymouth run past us.

Up front we showed little spark.

There was so much room behind their back four but we couldn’t find the killer pass.

We were strangely hesitant.

I watched the Shrewsbury game and thought on the whole we played pretty well.

Last night, when Plymouth were there for the taking, we wimped out.

[Ramarena]

1Wildsmith  6.5

12Smith  6

3Forsyth  6.5

6Cashin 6

15Roberts  6

22Springett  5.5

23White  5

9Collins  5

4Hourihane  6.5

7Sibley  6.5

11Mendez-Laing  7

38Knight  6

7Barkhuizen  6

18Dobbin  6

10McGoldrick  6.5

[Carnero]

1Wildsmith  6

12Smith  6

3Forsyth  6.5

6Cashin 6.5

15Roberts  6

22Springett  6

23White  5

9Collins  6

4Hourihane  5

7Sibley  6

11Mendez-Laing  6.5

38Knight  7

7Barkhuizen  6

18Dobbin  6

10McGoldrick  7

[Ilsonram12]

1Wildsmith 6

12Smith 6 

3Forsyth 7

6Cashin 6

15Roberts 5

22Springett 5

23White 5

9Collins 5

4Hourihane 6

7Sibley 6

11Mendez-Laing 6

38Knight 6

7Barkhuizen 5

18Dobbin 6

10McGoldrick 6

[rammieib]

1Wildsmith  6

12Smith  4 (really starting to question his value from RB - no goals, assists, missed passes, poor crosses)

3Forsyth  6

6Cashin 6

15Roberts  6

22Springett  5

23White  4

9Collins  5

4Hourihane  6

7Sibley  6

11Mendez-Laing  6.5

38Knight  6

7Barkhuizen  4

18Dobbin  5

10McGoldrick  6.5

[hintonsboots]

1Wildsmith  7 Can’t remember doing anything other than picking it out t’net

12Smith 6 Longest time to take a throw since Tyrone Mears

3Forsyth 7.5 MOTM Solid and still has a bit of pace

6Cashin 6 Needs to rein in the long diagonal. We need a centre back who can progress through the middle sometimes.

15Roberts 7  Fair performance wish he could cross it.

22Springett 6 Yet to convince me, thought he was a speed machine and expert crosser

23White 6  Should be making his mark at this level coming from the Lane.

9Collins 5.5 Not happening needs to ditch the Bullworker

4Hourihane 6 Good first half

7Sibley 6Want to see him in an attacking role

11Mendez-Laing 7Good finish, although over reliant on the step over 

38Knight7 Good energy, needs to get into box more.

7Barkhuizen 7 Always looks knackered to me, maybe an illusion.

18Dobbin 6.5 Pace but needs more end product.

10McGoldrick 7 Magical assist looks fitter every game.

[angieram]

1Wildsmith 6

12Smith 6

3Forsyth 7

6Cashin 6.5 

15Roberts 6

22Springett 6

23White 5.5 

9Collins 5

4Hourihane 5.5 

7Sibley 6

11Mendez-Laing 7

38Knight 6

7Barkhuizen 6

18Dobbin 6

10McGoldrick 6.5

Was at the game

[Rampant]

1Wildsmith     6

12Smith         5.5

3Forsyth        6.5

6Cashin         6

15Roberts      5.5

22Springett     6

23White         5

9Collins          4.5

4Hourihane      5.5

7Sibley            6

11Mendez-Laing     6

38Knight        6

7Barkhuizen      5

18Dobbin       5.5

10McGoldrick      6