Shrewsbury Town V Derby County: Ratings

[Ellafella]

Half-marks allowed; please rate all subs. Closes Thursday @ 18:00. Results by Thursday 22:00. Average is 6.00. Therefore, when a sub steps on the pitch he is on 6 - that's the baseline. Also indicate ATG (at the game) or TV (Tv).

1. Wildsmith

24.Nyambe

35.Nelson

6.Cashin

3.Forsyth

5. Bradley

12.Smith

14.Washington

22.Fornah

4.1Hourihane

17.Sibley

8.Bird

7.Barkhuizen

11.Méndez-Laing

9.Collins

10. Waghorn

[Ilsonram12]

1. Wildsmith 7

24.Nyambe 6

35.Nelson 6

6.Cashin 6

3.Forsyth 6

5. Bradley 6

12.Smith 5

14.Washington 6

22.Fornah 5

4.1Hourihane 6

17.Sibley 5

8.Bird 7

7.Barkhuizen 6

11.Méndez-Laing 6

9.Collins 5

10. Waghorn 6

[Guest]

1. Wildsmith - 8.5 - some really good saves and one might have been the best I've seen from a Derby goalie (maybe - will need to see it again!)

24.Nyambe - 6.5 - deserved more for effort but not as faultless today as in his previous matches and first time we've seen a wide opponent get the better of him now and again

35.Nelson - 6 - not at his settled and composed best. Perhaps not his fault but the long throw isn't as much of an asset as he (or PW?) thinks it is

6.Cashin - 7 - battled valiantly and saved us a few times, but also a bit erratic and passing radar still misfiring a little

3.Forsyth - 6 - one delightful ball to find Bird but otherwise average

5. Bradley - 5.5 - a three-minute cameo but half a mark deducted for a stupid and unconvincing dive

12.Smith - 4.5 - don't tend to reach for anything lower than a 5 but if 6 is average then he was at least 1.5 points below that! Really poor today. How he didn't get booked for constantly tugging shirts and grabbing on to opponents just because he couldn't "handle" them, I don't know

14.Washington - 6 - plenty of effort but limited in terms of what he could do from where he was

22.Fornah - 5 - he wasn't quite as bad as Smith... more of a 4.75 perhaps. Made bad decisions on the ball and was just nowhere near it for most of the half he played

4Hourihane - 6 - unlucky with the goal and put in a decent shift. Still not sure why he has a monopoly on set pieces

17.Sibley - 5.5 - thought he was lucky not to get subbed. Poor first half, slightly better in the second, but missed his best opportunity and didn't look hungry enough

8.Bird - 6 - tried to make things happen; less influential as the game went on

7.Barkhuizen - 5.5 - frustrating. At least he tried to be positive in front of goal. Would have liked to have seen him on the right. Powder-puff attempted clearance which put us back in danger was almost symbolic of how he, like a few others, is good but not good enough

11.Méndez-Laing - 5.5 - did nothing of note but can't penalise him too much for 30 minutes. His choice but I wouldn't complain if he announced his international retirement right about now as he seems to have less in the tank for us (not just this game)

9.Collins - 5 - another one of "those" performances unfortunately

10. Waghorn - 5.5 - tried hard, but nothing doing

Edited October 21, 2023 by jameso

[valakari]

Thats about right...i watched on TV

[rammieib]

1. Wildsmith 7.5 (but poor Pass led to goal)

24.Nyambe 6.5

35.Nelson 6.5

6.Cashin 6

3.Forsyth 6

5. Bradley 5 (too interested in a scrap)

12.Smith 4 (hurts us more than he helps)

14.Washington 7 (bright)

22.Fornah 4 - dog awful. Didn’t look interested 

4.1Hourihane 7

17.Sibley 6

8.Bird 7.5 - really tried to be a creative spark

7.Barkhuizen 5.5

11.Méndez-Laing 6

9.Collins 4 (completely bullied out)

10. Waghorn 4 (not sure what he offers in a deeper role)

[Ramarena]

1. Wildsmith 9

24.Nyambe 6

35.Nelson 6

6.Cashin 5

3.Forsyth 5

5. Bradley 5

12.Smith 5

14.Washington 5

22.Fornah 4

4.1Hourihane 7

17.Sibley 5

8.Bird 7

7.Barkhuizen 5

11.Méndez-Laing 5

9.Collins 4

10. Waghorn 6

[sage]

3 hours ago, Ellafella said:

Half-marks allowed; please rate all subs. Closes Thursday @ 18:00. Results by Thursday 22:00. Average is 6.00. Therefore, when a sub steps on the pitch he is on 6 - that's the baseline. Also indicate ATG (at the game) or TV (Tv).

1. Wildsmith 7.5

24.Nyambe 6

35.Nelson 6

6.Cashin 6

3.Forsyth 6

5. Bradley 5.5

12.Smith 5

14.Washington 6.5

22.Fornah 4.5

4.1Hourihane 6.5

17.Sibley 5

8.Bird 7.5

7.Barkhuizen 6

11.Méndez-Laing 6

9.Collins 6

10. Waghorn 6

 

[NottsRam77]

Wildsmith 8 mom for us.. great few saves, solid handling, great punch

24.Nyambe. 7. played well first half generally solid and good on the ball, could have responded a little Better when they had their little spell second half ..

35.Nelson 7 competed well, like nyambe could have responded better when they had their spell 

6.Cashin 7 same as nelson

3.Forsyth 7 same as nelson and cash

5. Bradley 6 nothing of note

12.Smith 5, ok in patches poor in more, kept leaving a huge gap for bayliss to walk into, showed for the ball 

14.Washington 6, nothing of note

22.Fornah 4, off it today, on the periphery of everything . Dont think he touched the ball for 15 mins.. seemed higher and a bit wider than previous

4.1Hourihane 6,  underwelming 

17.Sibley 4,  typical sibley starting performance.  first half one cross, little bit of link up play but clutching at straws really for someone whos deemed creative… ultimately offered very little

8.Bird 7 … tried to make things happen but when ur trying to link play with collins and barks u may as well not bother

7.Barkhuizen 2 .. absolute crap.. lost the ball everytime he got it.. did well with a controlled volley that could have gone in. But was needlessly offside god knows how many time and kept turning over possession making it impossible to build any pressure 

11.Méndez-Laing looked fast .. thats about it 6 

9.Collins huffed and puffed but quite simply isnt good enough to be the main man … will never make top two or even top 6 while hes our talisman 

10. Waghorn didnt know he came on.. well i did but nothing of note 6 

 

Tv 

Edited October 21, 2023 by NottsRam77

[bcnram]

1. Wildsmith  7

24.Nyambe  6

35.Nelson  6

6.Cashin  6

3.Forsyth  5

5. Bradley  6

12.Smith  5

14.Washington  7

22.Fornah  5

4.1Hourihane  7

17.Sibley  5

8.Bird  7

7.Barkhuizen  4

11.Méndez-Laing  5

9.Collins  5

10. Waghorn  6

[Ian Buxton's Bat]

ATG

1. Wildsmith  7

24.Nyambe  5

35.Nelson  7

6.Cashin  5.5

3.Forsyth  6.5

5. Bradley  5

12.Smith  5

14.Washington  6.5

22.Fornah  3

4.1Hourihane  7

17.Sibley  4.5

8.Bird  6

7.Barkhuizen  6

11.Méndez-Laing  5

9.Collins  6

10. Waghorn  6

[Dcfcsr92]

1. Wildsmith  8

24.Nyambe  5

35.Nelson  5

6.Cashin  5

3.Forsyth  4.5

5. Bradley  5

12.Smith  4

14.Washington  6.5

22.Fornah  3

4.1Hourihane  4

17.Sibley  3.5 (needs to play down the middle)

8.Bird  4

7.Barkhuizen  3.5

11.Méndez-Laing  3.5

9.Collins  4

10. Waghorn 3.5

[VulcanRam]

1 Wildsmith 8

24.Nyambe 6

35.Nelson 6

6.Cashin 6

3.Forsyth 6

5. Bradley 5.5

12.Smith 5

14.Washington 5

22.Fornah 5

4.1Hourihane 6

17.Sibley 5

8.Bird 7

7.Barkhuizen 6

11.Méndez-Laing 6

9.Collins 6

10. Waghorn 5

[Premier ram]

23 hours ago, Ellafella said:

Half-marks allowed; please rate all subs. Closes Thursday @ 18:00. Results by Thursday 22:00. Average is 6.00. Therefore, when a sub steps on the pitch he is on 6 - that's the baseline. Also indicate ATG (at the game) or TV (Tv).

1. Wildsmith - 7

24.Nyambe - 7 mr consistency

35.Nelson 7 defends so well

6.Cashin 6 still not at his best, Brighton really unsettled him

3.Forsyth - 6.5 should of had a penalty

5. Bradley - 6 

12.Smith - 5.5 alright in parts

14.Washington - 6

22.Fornah - 4 performances have dropped alarmingly

4.1Hourihane - 6 some good touches and intercept.potions

17.Sibley - 5.5 flitted in and out , should of scored

8.Bird - 6.5 class act , worked hard

7.Barkhuizen - 4 not his day

11.Méndez-Laing - 6

9.Collins - 4 cuts a frustrated figure when service is so poor

10. Waghorn - 6                                                     ATG