Jump to content

eddielewis

Member
  • Posts

    229
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by eddielewis

  1. 6 minutes ago, YorkshireRam said:

    Given Rotherham's limited financial capacity, and the disparity between the quality of our respective academies, straight comparisons aren't necessarily fair given these differences. Players under 23 tend to be expensive to sign due to value added for potential; for a team constantly scrapping to keep its head above water, it makes sense they targeted players in their prime rather than youngsters that need developing before hitting their stride?

    Yes a straight comparison isn't exactly possible with ourselves but Rotherham in my eyes are on par with Peterborough with their financial capacity yet they seem to do well with finding and improving young talent. Arguably Rotherham should be better placed with able to find young talent for their academy with bigger catchment of Sheffield/Yorkshire.

  2. 48 minutes ago, Waghorny said:

    Think a fair few will now be suggesting Hourihane in over Bird, wouldn't be opposed to that:

    Wildsmith
    Nyambe - Nelson - Cashin - Sibley
    Thompson - Hourihane - Fornah
    Wilson - Collins - NML

    Subs: Vickers, Ward, Bradley, Bird, Robinson, Barks, CBT

    Yeah doubt Bird will start with him travelling to Bristol to sign yesterday probably not in best frame of mind either.

  3. 32 minutes ago, StaffsRam said:

    Given the number of players out of contract in the summer we're going to have another rebuild job on our hands. With that comes the "they need time to gel" thing - If we don't go up this season there's probably a sub-conscious admission that we won't challenge next season either way.

    Which is why I think the sort of think the set up we kind of have with Warne greatly influencing the recruitment is kind of old fashioned. If you look at the modern examples of successful clubs living within their means Luton, Brighton, Brentford (theres more examples these are the most successful) they have all had a common link in which the recruitment is taken away from the manager nearly entirely. They have had managers come and go and it's not fazed them one bit. They have never had replace a whole XI because the new manager can't work with them. Managers kind come third now with philosophy - players - coach just because they usually last less than the players nowadays.

    What happens to the recruitment when we lose Warne be it a sacking or moving to another club. Do we hire another Manager that plays the same as Warne or do we go another route and have to sign players to match that Managers style. I just don't think our recruitment set up is future proofed.

  4. Probably this rests on them finalising the American striker Maguire they are tussling Blackburn to get through the door. Looks like Chansiri is also trying to knock off some money from Orlando for him which is making things difficult. Hopefully we have another target in mind because that has all the makings of a 10:59 deal.

  5. 1 minute ago, Gerry Daly said:

    They are getting one of the auto places for certain. Can we finish above Bolton and Peterborough for the other one? I wouldn’t bet much money on it would you?

    The Bolton game is huge in March will NML be available for that as I think it's international break and I don't think we will hit the quota of 3 call ups for a postponement unless Washington is back fit for a call up then?

  6. 3rd Based on the form tables of the last 10/15/20 games it's tight between the top 4. I don't think there's enough in any team to really pull away. Bolton and Portsmouth have difficult run ins but that doesn't meant much the way our performances have shown. If we want top 2 we can't afford to lose more than 2 more games based on the average amount of 2nd placed teams have had over the last 6 years. Not quite sure if we will lose NML for the international break in March (Bolton game) as Washington is injured so we won't fulfill the quota of international players to postpone the match.

  7. 2 minutes ago, Scott129 said:

    What is the point in our scouting department? What do they actually do all year?

    You could flip it the other way and say that Warne is hampering the scouting dept by shunning their suggestions to the point that these are the only available players.

    Whatever the truth is the football recruitment needs addressing. We're looking subpar and old fashioned.

  8. 5 minutes ago, roboto said:

    I would think the striker from a premier league club we’re waiting for might be Divin Mubama. West Ham are short on strikers, but he needs some proper game time that they can’t currently offer him.

    The is the problem now with 9 man sub benches Prem teams don't feel as guilty having one or two of their promising young players struggle for minutes because they feel they get 'enough' experience just hanging around the first team sub benches on matchdays and therefore it's so much harder for us and teams further down the pyramid to convince top teams for loans. You have to sell big clubs a proper plan of how were going to use their talent nowadays let alone crazy loan fees (which shouldn't exist in my view if they from prem clubs)

  9. 17 minutes ago, Comrade 86 said:

    He's played a blinder so far, get him in. Might be a tad expensive mind as his wage demands are significant and I fear he won't be as quick across the ground as our current left winger.

     

    15 minutes ago, Anag Ram said:

    Might find it difficult getting to the game as for some inexplicable reason the trains are unreliable.

    But at least he'll make sure the ticket office is open

×
×
  • Create New...