Derby County v Barnsley: Player Ratings

[Comrade 86]

1Wildsmith - 7.5 - excellent early save and ball distribution

24Nyambe - 7.0 - classy player, always look comfortable

5Bradley - 6.5 - still struggling with his confidence

35Nelson - 8.0 - another assured performance

6Cashin - 8.0 - reckon Cash has been doing some sprint training

3Forsyth - 8.5 - Foz is just Foz, nuff said really

4Hourihane - 7.0 - solid, if unspectacular

7Barkhuizen - 6.5 - can't fault his vision and ran hard all game, but ultimately a day to forget for Tom

17Sibley - 6.5 - cracking effort from outside the box reminds us of his threat, but profligate with the ball at times too

12Smith - 6.0 - I barely remember him so have perhaps unfairly marked him down a bit - soz Koz!

8Bird 🦅 - 7.0 - a controlled performance

11Méndez-Laing - 8.0 - poor FB was gutted by Nate on numerous occasions - head up though son! 

2Wilson - 8.5 - said on here a while back that he could be a big player for us and that's starting to look likely 

9Collins - 9.0 - the L1 Haaland

[Wolfie20]

1Wildsmith            7

24Nyambe            6

5Bradley                6

35Nelson              7.5

6Cashin                8

3Forsyth               7.5

4Hourihane          6.5

7Barkhuizen         6

17Sibley                6

12Smith                6.5

8Bird 🦅                6

11Méndez-Laing   7

2Wilson                 7.5

9Collins                 8.5

ATG

 

[bcnram]

1Wildsmith            6

24Nyambe            6

5Bradley                6

35Nelson              7

6Cashin                7

3Forsyth               6

4Hourihane          6

7Barkhuizen         6

17Sibley                6

12Smith                6

8Bird 🦅                6

11Méndez-Laing   7

2Wilson                 7

9Collins                 7

[England Ram]

ATM

1Wildsmith - 7 - His save in the first half kept us in the game  worth 1 point above average just for that. 

24Nyambe - 7 - solid again as a right back. This guy Will give you a solid 6/7 out of 10 defensively every week. If you expect anything going forward on a regular basis you will be disapointed, but does his job as a defender very well. 

5Bradley - 6 - Did his job in limited time. 

35Nelson - 7.5 - This guy is starting to really impress me. Imperious yesterday. Even after taking that dodgy elbow.  

6Cashin - 7.5 - Getting back to his best defensively as well as causing a nuisance up front. Assist and almost an assist with those flick ons for Fozzy’s goal and the fozzy shot leading to Colin’s second.  

3Forsyth - 7.5 - Defensively OK. Started to get beat a bit towards the end but he’d been used as an outlet all match and also caused havock up front with his late arrivals and goal and assist so still scores the same as the other defenders for his overall contribution. 

4Hourihane - 6 - Did his job OK. Nothing special and set pieces struggled to clear the front man. 

7Barkhuizen -  6 - Battled well, was an outlet before he tired. Should have been subbed 10 mins before his 1v1 as he was already knackered. Needs a goal. 

17Sibley - 6 - Limited time but was still able to make the keeper make a good save on to the woodwork from a tight angle. More of a chance than two of the other front 3 managed to combine. 

12Smith - 5 - Still think he’s the weak link of our team. Made a few simple passes and a tackle or two. One good forward pass for Barks chance. Besides that he looks lost most of the time and gave the ball away a few times in promising positions due to his poor passing or control and gets bypassed easily due to his poor midfield positioning.  

8Bird 🦅 - 6 - Average game by Max’s standards but still very effective. Should have scored with that lovely passing move.  

11Méndez-Laing - 7 - Excellent in the first half until he got that knock. Got people off their seats and excited every time he got it. 

2Wiloson - 7 - Great replacement for Laing and also exciting to watch in his shorter time. 

9Collins - 8 - MOTM. His best overall forward performance for the club. When the ball sticks to him he’s a different player and help to the team. 
 

fans -8 best atmosphere of the season so far. 

[Guest]

1Wildsmith - 7

24Nyambe - 7

5Bradley - 6

35Nelson - 7.5

6Cashin - 7.5

3Forsyth - 7.5

4Hourihane - 6.5

7Barkhuizen - 5

17Sibley - 6

12Smith - 7

8Bird - 7

11Méndez-Laing - 7.5

2Wilson - 7.5

9Collins - 7.5

[gfs1ram]

1Wildsmith                              7      Little to do but thought his distribution was good. + 2 good free kicks

24Nyambe                              7.5   Solid performance 

5Bradley                                 6      Did nothing wrong !!

35Nelson                                8      Excellent

6Cashin                                  8       Excellent. Cash's best game for a while. (but should have scored)

3Forsyth                                 9       My MoM.  Excellent defending. Good goal and assist. 

4Hourihane                             8      Thought he controlled the midfield especially second half.

7Barkhuizen                            7       Had a very good game but again missed some good chances.

17Sibley                                  6       Little time to make an impression but did hit the bar.

12Smith                                   7      Did OK

8Bird 🦅                                  7       Actually thought he was fairly anonymous especially first half.

11Méndez-Laing                    8       Continued his purple patch despite taking a knock first half.

2Wilson                                  8       Excellent when came on. Such a refreshing type of player.

9Collins                                  8.5    Probably his most effective game. Scored 2 and led the line well.

ATG

Edited November 12, 2023 by gfs1ram

[Topram]

Wildsmith 8 good free kicks solid in net

Nelson 8 some signing 

Nyambe 8 same as Nels

Cashin 8 best performance for a while 

Fozzy 8 same as Cash

Smith 8 solid worked hard 

Hourhaine 8 great balls into box worked hard

Bird 7 worked hard 

NML 8 beast last few weeks 

Barky 7.5 his goals will come better team with him in it

Collins 8.5 held hall up some good runs and bagged 2

 

 

[Premier ram]

On 11/11/2023 at 19:24, Ellafella said:

Half-marks allowed; please rate all subs. Closes Thursday @ 18:00. Results by Thursday 22:00. Average is 6.00. Therefore, when a sub steps on the pitch he is on 6 - that'sthe baseline. Also indicate ATG (at the game) or TV (Tv).

1Wildsmith 7 good save, hand in two of the goals

24Nyambe 6 carried an injury

5Bradley 6

35Nelson 8.5 had Cole in his pocket, immense

6Cashin 7.5 very good

3Forsyth 7 excellent performance

4Hourihane 7 worked hard

7Barkhuizen 6.5 did ok but what a miss

17Sibley 6

12Smith 6.5 did his job 

8Bird 🦅 6.5 quieter game for Max

11Méndez-Laing 8 tore Barnsley to shreds at times

2Wiloson 7.5 gets better every game

9Collins 8 probably Collos best performance

ATG