Rate the 23/24 signings

[S8TY]

Curtis Nelson  10/10
Callum Elder     6/10
Joe Ward    7/10
Sonny Bradley    8/10
Josh Vickers   7/10
Kane Wilson    8/10
Martyn Waghorn   6/10
Conor Washington   6/10
Tyrese Fornah   5/10
Elliot Embleton   4/10
Ryan Nyambe   8/10
Tyreece John-Jules   7/10

Winter:

Ebou Adams 11/10 lol
Dwight Gayle 8/10
Corey Blackett-Taylor 6/10
Max Bird* 8/10

 

Extensions:
Nathaniel Mendez-Laing  9/10
Eiran Cashin    9/10
Jake Rooney  7/10

Edited April 30 by S8TY

[Srg]

Curtis Nelson: 10
Callum Elder: 4
Joe Ward: 6
Sonny Bradley: 4
Josh Vickers: 6
Kane Wilson: 8
Martyn Waghorn: 4
Conor Washington: 5 
Tyrese Fornah: 6
Elliot Embleton: 1
Ryan Nyambe: 8
Tyreece John-Jules: 5

Winter:

Ebou Adams: 10
Dwight Gayle: 7
Corey Blackett-Taylor: 6
Max Bird*: 7

Extensions:
Nathaniel Mendez-Laing: 9
Eiran Cashin: 10
Jake Rooney: 8

[LeedsCityRam]

On 25/04/2024 at 10:46, Animal is a Ram said:

Summer window:

Curtis Nelson
Callum Elder
Joe Ward
Sonny Bradley
Josh Vickers
Kane Wilson
Martyn Waghorn
Conor Washington
Tyrese Fornah
Elliot Embleton
Ryan Nyambe
Tyreece John-Jules

Winter:

Ebou Adams
Dwight Gayle
Corey Blackett-Taylor
Max Bird*

*I've included Max, as I feel it was crucial we had him to the end of the season.

Extensions:
Nathaniel Mendez-Laing
Eiran Cashin
Jake Rooney  

 

Ratings out of 10, please. I might do some statistical analysis.

Summer window:

Curtis Nelson 10 - not really sure you could ask for much more. Played every minute & player of the year
Callum Elder 6 - solid enough when fit but suffered from injuries. Also not a LWB
Joe Ward 6.5 - lot of potential there & a stellar display at Portsmouth but conceded some rash penalties. Not a RB
Sonny Bradley 6 - improved later on in the season defensively & offered attacking threat but well below standard first half of season
Josh Vickers 6.5 - solid enough but looked more jittery than I'd have liked when he got his first team chance
Kane Wilson 7 - infectious character & popped up with some crucial game changing moments. Solid at RB. Feel he is capable of more in that final 3rd though
Martyn Waghorn 7 - superb hattrick at Peterborough & won us some crucial points early on. Injury destroyed his season sadly
Conor Washington 6 - another affected by injury but never really settled as a first choice. Bit of a letdown as the marquee signing alongside Bradley
Tyrese Fornah 5 - really disappointed overall as there's definite potential there but seemingly a poor EFL Trophy display convinced Warne not to give him another chance. He could do with observing Ebou as sure that was the role he was earmarked for
Elliot Embleton 0 - his welcome interview looked more like an ISIS hostage video & he left shortly after with a season ending injury. Complete waste of money
Ryan Nyambe 8 - excellent signing. Looked very accomplished at RB & RCB and could definitely make the step up to Championship. Not a RWB though Warne. Sadly missed end of season with injury
Tyreece John-Jules 5.5 - winner at Port Vale & provided a pacey option off the bench but injury meant we saw very little of him. Looked a little lightweight at times when given more minutes

Winter:

Ebou Adams 10 - the difference between us going up & not going up
Dwight Gayle 7.5 - yes injury meant he played very little overall but his arrival gave the side fresh impetus. He was also extremely dangerous in the final 3rd. I wouldn't be averse to offering him another year
Corey Blackett-Taylor 6 - seemingly not trusted by Warne & murmurs he struggled to adapt to training standards. Best display was at Pompey but a shocking miss at Wycombe really shook his confidence
Max Bird* 8 - the edge in class we needed at times. Really sad to lose him now we've gone up, we need someone exactly like him

Extensions:
Nathaniel Mendez-Laing 9 - often our main game changer. Tired towards back end of season but still won us a lot of crucial points
Eiran Cashin 10 - absolute class at the back with Nelson
Jake Rooney  6.5 - started season well & looks a prospect. Do see him as a CB/DCM rather than a RB though

[Ramarena]

Summer window:

Curtis Nelson 10
Callum Elder 4
Joe Ward 6.5
Sonny Bradley 6
Josh Vickers 6
Kane Wilson 7.5
Martyn Waghorn 5.5
Conor Washington 5.5
Tyrese Fornah 5
Elliot Embleton 1
Ryan Nyambe 8
Tyreece John-Jules 5

Winter:

Ebou Adams 10
Dwight Gayle 8
Corey Blackett-Taylor 5.5
Max Bird* 7