Player Ratings #6: v Birmingham (a)

[sage]

On 10/09/2021 at 19:06, Rampant said:

Usual rules. Average performance is a 6.0 and half marks allowed. Deadline Sunday 9pm.

 

Roos 5

Byrne 7

Buchanan 6

Jagielka 7

Davies 6

Shinnie 5

Bird 6

Morrison 5.5

Sibley 5

Lawrence 5.5

Baldock 5.5

Stretton 6

(add others as you see fit)

 

 

[England Ram]

On 10/09/2021 at 22:26, JarodyDCFC said:

Roos- 3 Really bad. Distribution was terrible, had no presence in his box yet again. Need someone else in goal ASAP. 

Byrne- 6 Was decent at the start but his positioning was so so poor. I know it’s part of our game to play the fullbacks up high but both Birmingham goals were scored on his side of the pitch and he was nowhere to be seen. 

Buchanan- 6 Messed up for the first goal but at times seemed like our only player who wanted to make something happen. A couple of great runs and positive passes unfortunately cancelled out by a terrible backpass. 

Jagielka- 6 Thought he tried his best but his age really showed tonight. Just struggled to keep up with Birmingham at times. 

Davies- 5 He’s been great so far this year but this was a really weird performance from him. At times his positioning and defensive work just seemed very lazy. Think he just had an off game. 

Shinnie- 6 He wasn’t terrible or anything in the first half. He was fine. Nothing bad nor nothing good to say about him. Maybe if he’d stayed he’d have injected some more energy into the team but on the flipside maybe he’d have gotten sent off. 

Bird- 5 At times he showed his natural ability but tonight he was just very negative and ultimately didn’t affect the game at all. 

Morrison- 3 Dreadful performance, dreadful attitude. Needs to realise he’s not too good for the championship, attempted to run the entire length of the pitch twice and got easily tackled which a better team than Birmingham would’ve capitalised on. 

Sibley- 4 Poor from Sibbo tonight. Might as well not have been on the pitch he was that anonymous. 

Lawrence- 5 Another poor performance. Not sure what he did that was any good other than one shot straight at their keeper. When was the last time he scored a free kick? Also was being a twit all night, not setting a great example as captain so far. 

Baldock- 5 Oh yeah he was playing. Gets a customary five for just showing up.

I was going to do mine but read this and thought…..spot on!!! 
 

please take these as my ratings as well. 

[Rampant]

Deadline has been and gone. I'm only just beginning to tally the ratings up now so will include the above two but no more please.

[Rampant]

 Safe to say that the top ten performances of the season remains unchanged after the trip to St Andrews.

 1  Phil Jagielka                 8.27  vs Hull (a)

 2  Max Bird                        8.18  vs Hull (a)

 3  Phil Jagielka                7.95  vs Middlesbrough (h)

 4  Curtis Davies              7.85  vs Hull (a)

 5  Tom Lawrence            7.60  vs Forest (h)

 6  Craig Forsyth              7.50  vs Huddersfield (h)

 7  Curtis Davies               7.45  vs Middlesbrough (h)

 8  Graeme Shinnie           7.43  vs Middlesbrough (h)

 9  Sam Baldock                7.35  vs Hull (a)

10 Kamil Jozwiak             7.34  vs Hull (a)     

 

Player Ratings vs Birmingham

Phil Jagielka                5.65

Nathan Byrne              5.61

Lee Buchanan             5.47

Curtis Davies              5.38

Max Bird                        5.32

Ravel Morrison            5.26

Jack Stretton              5.04

Kelle Roos                   4.88

Tom Lawrence            4.82

Graeme Shinnie          4.71

Sam Baldock               4.68

Louie Sibley                4.38

* Both Dylan Williams and Jason Knight received one rating apiece which will count towards their overall rating but not this match on its own

 

MotM Awards

Phil Jagielka      3

Craig Forsyth     1

Louie Sibley       1

Tom Lawrence   1

 

Podium Placings

Curtis Davies       4

Phil Jagielka         3

Craig Forsyth       2

Max Bird              2

Kelle Roos            1

Louie Sibley         1

Ravel Morrison     1

Graeme Shinnie    1

Tom Lawrence      1

Nathan Byrne       1

Lee Buchanan      1

 

Overall Season Rating

Only six players are currently averaging over 6.50. The top six therefore at present are:

Phil Jagielka          7.29

Curtis Davies        6.86

Max Bird                6.61

Kamil Jozwiak       6.58

Craig Forsyth        6.55

Ravel Morrison      6.52

Edited September 13, 2021 by Rampant