Jump to content

Player Ratings #9 : vs Sheff Utd (a)


Rampant
 Share

Recommended Posts

Posting this in case I can't sort it later. Your ratings for our heroes are invited. Average performance is a 6.0. Half marks accepted. Deadline of 2100 Sunday. COYR.

Roos

Byrne

Buchanan

Jagielka

Davies

Shinnie

Bird

Morrison

Sibley

Lawrence

Baldock

(add subs as you see fit)

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, Rampant said:

Posting this in case I can't sort it later. Your ratings for our heroes are invited. Average performance is a 6.0. Half marks accepted. Deadline of 2100 Sunday. COYR.

Roos 4 - Not a sending off for me but still took us out of the game

Byrne 6

Buchanan 7

Jagielka 7.5

Davies 6 - what on earth was he doing? Decent until then

Shinnie 6.5

Bird 7

Morrison 5

Sibley 6.5

Lawrence 6.5

Baldock 5

Allsop 5.5

Knight 6

Jozwiak 6.5

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Roos 0 - we would have won this game with 11 men on the pitch  

Byrne - 7

Buchanan - 7

Jagielka - 9 awesome  

Davies - 9 would have been 10 but for the handball…. Still amazing performance though 

Shinnie - 10 outstanding  

Bird - 8 another solid game 

Morrison - 4 didn’t notice he was on the pitch really 

Sibley 3 the only time I spotted him was when he was pulled up for being offside all the time 

Lawrence 5 oh Thomas, what were you doing at the end…?

Baldock 4 should have scored but lacked much service. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 hours ago, Rampant said:

Posting this in case I can't sort it later. Your ratings for our heroes are invited. Average performance is a 6.0. Half marks accepted. Deadline of 2100 Sunday. COYR.

Roos 8

Byrne 7

Buchanan 7

Jagielka 8

Davies 7

Shinnie 9

Bird 8

Morrison 5

Sibley 6

Lawrence 6

Baldock 6

(add subs as you see fit)

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Roos - 4.5         Before the red was probably going to give a 7 but that mistake changed the game.

Byrne - 6           Decent.

Buchanan - 6    Decent. 

Jagielka - 9       Immense. 

Davies - 8.5      Until the 88th min fantastic. What on earth was he doing with his arm though!?

Shinnie - 9.5     Brilliant. In my opinion he's our real captain.

Bird - 7.5           Another good display. At his best when we up the tempo and he looks/drives forward. 

Morrison - 5.5   Very quiet. 

Sibley - 5.5      Would be so much better playing no.10, he's not a winger. 

Lawrence - 5.5 Infuriating. Every single shot, head down, kick it as hard as can, aim for the middle and hope it swerves either side

Baldock - 4     Was he even on the pitch? Missed a great chance with his left foot is all i can remember him doing

 

Jozwiak - 7  Made a difference when he came on, even with 10 men. Pace is a threat, quick feet, good link up play.

Knight - 6    Extra energy and pressing when he came on, decent cameo.

Allsop - 6.5  Did well given the circumstances. Caught crosses, made saves. Did nothing wrong. 

Edited by Chris_Martin
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, Chris_Martin said:

Roos - 4.5         Before the red was probably going to give a 7 but that mistake changed the game.

Byrne - 6           Decent.

Buchanan - 6    Decent. 

Jagielka - 9       Immense. 

Davies - 8.5      Until the 88th min fantastic. What on earth was he doing with his arm though!?

Shinnie - 9.5     Brilliant. In my opinion he's our real captain.

Bird - 7.5           Another good display. At his best when we up the tempo and he looks/drives forward. 

Morrison - 5.5   Very quiet. 

Sibley - 5.5      Would be so much better playing no.10, he's not a winger. 

Lawrence - 5.5 Infuriating. Every single shot, head down, kick it as hard as can, aim for the middle and hope it swerves either side

Baldock - 4     Was he even on the pitch? Missed a great chance with his left foot is all i can remember him doing

 

Jozwiak - 7  Made a difference when he came on, even with 10 men. Pace is a threat, quick feet, good link up play.

Knight - 6    Extra energy and pressing when he came on, decent cameo.

Allsop - 6.5  Did well given the circumstances. Caught crosses, made saves. Did nothing wrong. 

So you dock Roos 2.5 points for a mistake that didn't cost a goal but give Davies an 8.5 despite the mistake that did?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 minutes ago, angieram said:

So you dock Roos 2.5 points for a mistake that didn't cost a goal but give Davies an 8.5 despite the mistake that did?

It's still possible to win from a goal down. It's not with 10 men. Roos's mistake had much more of an impact.

Edited by Chris_Martin
Link to comment
Share on other sites

23 minutes ago, Rampant said:

Not a large pool of ratings this time around but the top three were:

MotM     8.39   Shinnie

               8.00   Jagielka

               7.78    Bird

Thanks, Rampant. I couldn't vote having listened to the match on Radio Derby and therefore not having the foggiest idea who played well. Back to it on Wednesday, though.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account.

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.