Jump to content

Chip Eaters v Derby Match Ratings


sage

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 20
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Roos - 6 didn't do anything wrong and could not have done anything about the goal

Byrne - 7 Thought he was our best player and has been all season

Buchanan - 6 tried hard got caught out a couple of times but tried to get forward

Wisdom - 5 some good things  but also some not so good things  not one of his better games

Mengi - 6 his speed gets him out of things played well

Clarke - 7 along with Bryne our best player, dominant   

Shinnie  - 6 gives it his all, got caught in midfield a few times

Knight - 5 gave his all but struggled in midfield

Roberts - 4 flatters to deceive, seems afraid to shoot 

CKR - 5 you could tell he was carrying an injury and lived off scraps

Sibley - 5 not his game, tried but shackled by his opposite number 

Wayne - 6 cannot complain about his selection or subs, not sure what else he could have done 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Roos - 6- Made a good save and commanded his area. Couldn’t do much for the goal, would have been suicidal to come out for it and you’d expect your defenders to deal with that. 

Byrne - 7- Got is going forward more than most but because he is the only option most of the time then the opposition know to double up on that side. 

Buchanan - 6- Average display. 

Wisdom - 4. Gave them the ball to put us under pressure for the goal and was absent in defence for the goal. Slow on the ball and caught out over the top too many times as well. 

Mengi - 6 - His best game for us. Still positionally poor but an improvement. 

Clarke - 7 Best of the back line. Covers for others as well as trying to get us forward. 

Shinnie - 6 - Good in the challenge but loses the ball almost as much as he gets it back. 

Knight - 5 - Woeful first half and had no impact on the game. Second half helped the press but too much poor control and obsessed with giving it to Byrne and not looking inside or over the top for runners. 

Roberts - 6 - Actually had an impact out of the front 3 but was on to a looser with Colin playing half baked. 

CKR - 3 - Worst game for us. Could tell he was nursing himself through the game and wasted the 2 opportunities he had. 

Sibley - 4 - Played out of position and struggled to get in the game. Also hampered with the press with Colin taking the game off. 

 

Bird- 2 - His worst performance for us.  He had to give the foul after Wisdom gave it away but all the rest of his fouls, bad passes, weak tackles and general poor play was all on him.  

Lawrence - 6 - Tried to make something happen at least. 

Jozwiak - 6- Made some good passes, pressed hard and created some chances. 

Cresswell - 5 - Felt for him because most of his runs ignored and when he was played in it was massively over hit all the time. 

Watson - 5 Couldn’t influence the game as we played it over the top and around him. 
 

Nothing felt good about watching this game. For the first time since coming out of the relegation zone I feel we will end up back in it and relegated if this doesn’t drastically improve. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Roos 7 - thought he was good today actually. Couple of routine saves but was impressed with his composure from crosses (much improved) & in possession. Couldnt do much about the goal

Byrne 6 - busy but struggled to get into decent positions because of their width

Buchanan 6 - much improved from other night. Defensively & aerially strong. Struggled like Byrne to get into positions to deliver into the box

Wisdom 5 - not great. Ball watching too much & felt should have been closest to their lad for the goal. Offered nothing from a possession point of view other than dithering

Mengi 6 - pretty good defensively although Clarke had to bail him out a couple of times. Still looks awkward on the ball

Clarke 7 MOM - composed as ever at the back & did a lot of unsung work covering for Mengi & Buchanan

Shinnie 4 - very poor. Constantly lost possession whether it was being caught on the ball or launching aimless passes to no-one. Along with Knight, a key reason why we could not establish any control of the match. Also expected much better pressing in midfield but there again, was far too deep

Knight 4 - also very poor. Similarly poor on the ball either going backwards or aimless punts. Barely pressed because he was so deep & lost his man for the goal also

Roberts 6 - had very little decent ball & often had 3 defenders around him. Beat a lot of them by crabbing sideways but very little to aim at in the box. Needs more help & options

CKR 5 - couple of exquisite touches but simply not fit. Also starved of any quality service

Sibley 5 - was disappointed with his pressing & often a passenger. In mitigation, he had virtually nothing of quality coming into him & was on the wing (where there was a lot of traffic) not number 10. Best effort of the match with his shot after half time

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Roos - 5

Byrne - 6

Buchanan - 4

Wisdom - 4 caught out alot

Mengi -  4 unsettled back line since we changed to fit him/edmundson in - but not his fault

Clarke - 6

Shinnie - 6

Knight - 5

Roberts - 5

CKR - 3 again not his fault but shouldnt have been played injured as couldnt do a lot

Sibley - 5 but didnt seem to know his role

Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 hours ago, England Ram said:

Roos - 6- Made a good save and commanded his area. Couldn’t do much for the goal, would have been suicidal to come out for it and you’d expect your defenders to deal with that. 

Byrne - 7- Got is going forward more than most but because he is the only option most of the time then the opposition know to double up on that side. 

Buchanan - 6- Average display. 

Wisdom - 4. Gave them the ball to put us under pressure for the goal and was absent in defence for the goal. Slow on the ball and caught out over the top too many times as well. 

Mengi - 6 - His best game for us. Still positionally poor but an improvement. 

Clarke - 7 Best of the back line. Covers for others as well as trying to get us forward. 

Shinnie - 6 - Good in the challenge but loses the ball almost as much as he gets it back. 

Knight - 5 - Woeful first half and had no impact on the game. Second half helped the press but too much poor control and obsessed with giving it to Byrne and not looking inside or over the top for runners. 

Roberts - 6 - Actually had an impact out of the front 3 but was on to a looser with Colin playing half baked. 

CKR - 3 - Worst game for us. Could tell he was nursing himself through the game and wasted the 2 opportunities he had. 

Sibley - 4 - Played out of position and struggled to get in the game. Also hampered with the press with Colin taking the game off. 

 

Bird- 2 - His worst performance for us.  He had to give the foul after Wisdom gave it away but all the rest of his fouls, bad passes, weak tackles and general poor play was all on him.  

Lawrence - 6 - Tried to make something happen at least. 

Jozwiak - 6- Made some good passes, pressed hard and created some chances. 

Cresswell - 5 - Felt for him because most of his runs ignored and when he was played in it was massively over hit all the time. 

Watson - 5 Couldn’t influence the game as we played it over the top and around him. 
 

Nothing felt good about watching this game. For the first time since coming out of the relegation zone I feel we will end up back in it and relegated if this doesn’t drastically improve. 

Agree with pretty much all this.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Roos 6

Byrne 6

Buchanan 5

Wisdom 4

Mengi 6

Clarke 7

Shinnie 4 

Knight 4 - don't see why he keeps starting games, yes has lots of energy but can't create anything, can't pass, can't beat anyone for pace. Bit like Shinnie really.

Roberts 5 - at least tried to attack

CKR 4 - shouldn't have played

Sibley 5 - played out of position and just had long-balls lumped at him

Bird 2 - shocking, unless he was passing to the ballboy behind the goal

Cresswell 5 - shame he had to make his debut in such a poor game but made some good runs, pity nobody has the vision to see them. 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...