Jump to content

Milwall v Derby Player Ratings


sage

Recommended Posts

Everyone seems very happy which seems weird for us, so let's have a thread where we can disagree with each other

Hamer 6 - Couldn't do anything with either goal and made 1 good save but terrified me with the ball at his feet

Bogle 7 - Did well going forward but gave the ball away for the first goal

Forsyth 6 - Got outmuscled for the first goal, but got an assist for the third

Clarke 6 - General play was very good, but should have taken the responsibility for both goals

Wisdom 5 - Was decent apart from when he thought he was Franz Beckenbauer which was far too often

Bird 7 - Did well but now needs to take more responsibility with ambitious passes

Rooney 7 - Controlled the first half, but struggled when they pressed 

Holmes 5 - Had a poor game. Struggled with how congested it was on the right hand side in the first half.

Sibley 9 - Would have had a 10 (and 5 goals) if his right foot was as good as his left. Bloody brilliant though.

Lawrence 4 - Continuously gave the ball and made an error for their second goal.

Waghorn 7 - Held the ball up well , hit the bar with the free kick and set up the second nicely.

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 50
  • Created
  • Last Reply
1 minute ago, sage said:

Everyone seems very happy which seems weird for us, so let's have a thread where we can disagree with each other

Hamer 6 - Couldn't do anything with either goal and made 1 good save but terrified me with the ball at his feet

Bogle 7 - Did well going forward but gave the ball away for the first goal

Forsyth 6 - Got outmuscled for the first goal, but got an assist for the third

Clarke 6 - General play was very good, but should have taken the responsibility for both goals

Wisdom 5 - Was decent apart from when he thought he was Franz Beckenbauer which was far too often

Bird 7 - Did well but now needs to take more responsibility with ambitious passes

Rooney 7 - Controlled the first half, but struggled when they pressed 

Holmes 5 - Had a poor game. Struggled with how congested it was on the right hand side in the first half.

Sibley 9 - Would have had a 10 (and 5 goals) if his right foot was as good as his left. Bloody brilliant though.

Lawrence 4 - Continuously gave the ball and made an error for their second goal.

Waghorn 7 - Held the ball up well , hit the bar with the free kick and set up the second nicely.

 

 

Would change Clarke’s mark to a seven. The second was down to Curtis Davies. Couldn’t get off the ground from a standing start. Sign of old knees.

Mind you, Wisdom was asleep too.

Lawrence was probably a five. He put himself about, but as you say, was poor in possession.

I was worried when we made defensive subs.

Glad that we didn’t adopt a defensive approach.

Great day (Millwall were poo).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

11 minutes ago, KBB said:

Amazing we won with those ratings. Should have lost by a fair few with only bogle out of the back 5 getting a 7.

You could always state your own. We did concede 2 and they missed 2 one on ones.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

14 minutes ago, Anag Ram said:

Would change Clarke’s mark to a seven. The second was down to Curtis Davies. Couldn’t get off the ground from a standing start. Sign of old knees.

Mind you, Wisdom was asleep too.

Lawrence was probably a five. He put himself about, but as you say, was poor in possession.

I was worried when we made defensive subs.

Glad that we didn’t adopt a defensive approach.

Great day (Millwall were poo).

Davies was always going to struggle as he was stood underneath it. Thats why Clarke should have gone for it and Davies blocked the players run.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hamer-7       Did the basics well, couple of strong saves
Bogle-8        2nd quarter was very strong and created our opening goal
Wisdom-6    Did okay but lost possession a few times
Clarke-7       Solid
Forsyth-6.5     Good assist but suspect defensively     
Rooney-7     Dictated majority of the game 
Bird-8           Another remarkably solid performance 
Holmes-6     A tad anonymous but did bits well
Lawrence-6.5   Struggled to make an impact but great endeavour, especially defensively 2nd half
Sibley-10      MotM (obviously), our most creative player and biggest offensive threat
Waghorn-6   Great touch for the assist but struggled to get into the game against their giant CBs

Davies-6      Helped aerially but could have done better for late goal
Shinnie-7     Combative performance and won lots in the air
Evans-5        Can't remember him doing anything but not being overly-critical
Knight- 6      Pretty anonymous on a very congested right wing
Martin-7       Brilliant pass to create 3rd and couple of nice flicks, as per usual
 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hamer 6 - Couple of important saves, shockingly bad distribution. Think he hit every goal kick out of play.

Bogle 7 - Some important tackles in defence, and was involved a lot in some neat bits of interplay in the Brighton half. Lovely assist for the opener too.

Wisdom 6 - Poor from Andre today. Generally sound on the ball, but clocked off far too many times defensively and looked a little unfit.

Clarke 7 - Distribution could have been better, but he dealt with the aerial threat well and rescued Wisdom on multiple occasions.

Forsyth 7 - Brilliant quick thinking for the assist of Sibley’s third, and looked threatening in possession in Brighton’s half all game.

Rooney 7 - Literally always on the ball. A couple of poor rusty passes, but generally dictated the game

Bird 7 - Similar to Rooney, always on the ball and controlled possession. Almost never gave the gall away.

Holmes 6 - Don’t particularly like him outwide. Generally kept possession well but largely ineffective.

Sibley 10 MOTM - Perfection. Hat trick and the Millwall defence didn’t have a clue what to do with him. Nothing more needs to be said.

Lawrence 7 - Always made himself available in and around the Millwall box, and was pretty solid in possession generally. Tracked back well second half too.

Waghorn 7 - Unlucky not to score with his freekick, and a beautiful assist for the second. Made a nuisance of himself up front and generally did well.

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 minutes ago, Millenniumram said:

Forsyth 7 - Brilliant quick thinking for the assist of Sibley’s third, and looked threatening in possession in Brighton’s half all game.

 

 

 

 

Take it you had Brighton v Arsenal on when you were writing this? ?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 hours ago, Millenniumram said:

Hamer 6 - Couple of important saves, shockingly bad distribution. Think he hit every goal kick out of play.

Bogle 7 - Some important tackles in defence, and was involved a lot in some neat bits of interplay in the Brighton half. Lovely assist for the opener too.

Wisdom 6 - Poor from Andre today. Generally sound on the ball, but clocked off far too many times defensively and looked a little unfit.

Clarke 7 - Distribution could have been better, but he dealt with the aerial threat well and rescued Wisdom on multiple occasions.

Forsyth 7 - Brilliant quick thinking for the assist of Sibley’s third, and looked threatening in possession in Brighton’s half all game.

Rooney 7 - Literally always on the ball. A couple of poor rusty passes, but generally dictated the game

Bird 7 - Similar to Rooney, always on the ball and controlled possession. Almost never gave the gall away.

Holmes 6 - Don’t particularly like him outwide. Generally kept possession well but largely ineffective.

Sibley 10 MOTM - Perfection. Hat trick and the Millwall defence didn’t have a clue what to do with him. Nothing more needs to be said.

Lawrence 7 - Always made himself available in and around the Millwall box, and was pretty solid in possession generally. Tracked back well second half too.

Waghorn 7 - Unlucky not to score with his freekick, and a beautiful assist for the second. Made a nuisance of himself up front and generally did well.

 

So Lawrence was as good as Bird?

Er.........ok. ?‍♂️

Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 minutes ago, Woodley Ram said:

I would give Sibley 1 out of 10 as I want to see him play for us next year, the way he is playing I bet the perm scouts are pissed off they can’t see him in the flesh. Would be surprised if we have a couple of bids for him in the summer 

This perm scout is well pissed off he can't see Sibbo in the flesh. ?

images.jpeg-59.jpg.2da9f185e480cbf51ef622c9a28a8528.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...