Jump to content

should he stay or should he go ?


nfb

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 36
  • Created
  • Last Reply

To go 

Razza (I think it's probably for the best for him and family?)

Blackman (PLEASEEEEEEEEEE)

Weimann

Bryson 

Roos

Bent (think he'll be going but he got 1 year further option to take it up so don't know what is going to happen then) 

Baird (will he want to stay as back up? Again he got one year further option to take it up) 

And maybe Olsson? Unless Fozzy battle with Russell and other winger for LW.. 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Camara, Blackman, Anya, Shackell, Christie, Johnson, Butterfield, Russell, Weimann, Bent I would imagine will be moved on in the next year.

Russell could survive the cull if he puts a fighting display in.

After this season I don't think anyone is safe and I won't shed a tear for any of them should they leave.

I would swap our most talented of players for someone with the passion and the fight that Jake Buxton had.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

V.hard to know how GR will see certain players but at risk have to be:

Bent (age), Baird (age), Blackman (literally not sure what he is for), Camara (not a footballer), Olsson (providing Fozzy is fit for pre-season), Weimann (though I can see Rowett wanting a look at him), Shackell (wages high if not 1st choice), Bryson (time to move on or will his work rate be just what GR wants?), Russell (same as Bryson), Anya (not sure he's added much but again GR may like his work rate), Johnson (might depend on Thorne, but high earner that has never quite looked right here), Butterfield (not really worked out for him but another that a new manager may get more out of).

Those who I'd suspect will stay:

Carson, Mitchell, Keogh, Pearce, Christie, Lowe, Fozzy, Thorne, Hughes (big offers dependent), Ince (Big offers dependent), Martin, Nugent, Vydra, plus various young players from U23s like Bennett, Max-Elsnik etc

Link to comment
Share on other sites

To go: Bent, Shackell, Camara, Olsson, Weimann, Bryson, Anya, Christie (provided we bring in a replacement) and potentially Butterfield.

I know a lot of people want Blackman and Vydra gone, but I think the two could offer something in a Rowett side. I suspect the latter certainly will.

I also think we'll need to bring in 5 or 6 new guys in the summer. 2 new defenders (RB & CB), 3 midfielders (winger and two central) and a striker to replace Bent. 

Would like to see Callum Guy and Elsnik in and around the first team too. Guy could be the new Bryson. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Under McClaren I could tell you exactly who I'd get rid of and keep, but it's sort of premature to make any judgements before we've even seen Rowett manage one game.

Easier to say at the end of the season, right now I'd obviously want to keep Ince and Hughes, but if it looks like Rowett doesn't have much use for them, then I'd be open to selling them on for the money.

Equally, players like Weimann and Anya are players I'd have been happy to see go in the summer but might be really effective under Rowett, we know he likes playing with a counter attacking three behind a hold up striker, so they could very well fit the bill for him.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

27 minutes ago, kash_a_ram_a_ding_dong said:

To go

Vydra 

Weiman

Blackman

Baird

Razza

Ollson

Bent

Feel a bit sorry for bent and Baird as both have done very well this year but both are ageing and at the end of their careers

 

Agree, but I would add Butterfield to the list, although how we attract any kind of fee for this rather pedestrian footballer I don't know. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

46 minutes ago, JuanFloEvraTheCocu'sNesta said:

I think we will be saying goodbye to Bent and Baird. Not because they have done anything wrong but because they are ageing and probably in the upper bracket of wages.

In terms of 'shipping out'  it is hard to say because Rowett might have his own ideas but I think Blackman, Camara and Shackell could be on the list.

Giving you a like for spelling ageing correct as much as anything else. Grammar Police rule :ph34r:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

44 minutes ago, Derby_EnglandLoyal said:

To go 

Razza (I think it's probably for the best for him and family?)

Blackman (PLEASEEEEEEEEEE)

Weimann

Bryson 

Roos

Bent (think he'll be going but he got 1 year further option to take it up so don't know what is going to happen then) 

Baird (will he want to stay as back up? Again he got one year further option to take it up) 

And maybe Olsson? Unless Fozzy battle with Russell and other winger for LW.. 

 

I'm sure another Championship outfit would fancy Bent. May not be big bucks but he'd definitely do a job, I agree best if he sought pastures new 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The Keepers and keepers, and for me I'd retain everyone from the defence - If we got a decent offer for Shackell, Olly or Fozzy I'd consider it but would have to be decent...

Then the players I'd keep are Hughes (assuming no £25m bids), Thorne, Hanson, Ince, Russell, Vydra, Nugent and try to make sure Martin comes back... I'd still like to see Blackman come good too but faith is waning... Excluding any u23s who have been around like Bennett. Just keep all the u23s just in case.

Everyone else is fair game to go I think

Link to comment
Share on other sites

For me...

To go: Bent, Blackman, Camara, Olsson, Weimann, Butterfield, Christie... maybe Bryson depending on the role GR sees for him. Hanson should go on loan for a season.

Keep: I'd give Baird an extension. Was class at RB during our high point and unlocked Ince. Anya's not had a fair crack of the whip in my view... Vydra should stay and get a proper pre-season and chance under a new manager.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

8 minutes ago, cheron85 said:

The Keepers and keepers, and for me I'd retain everyone from the defence - If we got a decent offer for Shackell, Olly or Fozzy I'd consider it but would have to be decent...

Then the players I'd keep are Hughes (assuming no £25m bids), Thorne, Hanson, Ince, Russell, Vydra, Nugent and try to make sure Martin comes back... I'd still like to see Blackman come good too but faith is waning... Excluding any u23s who have been around like Bennett. Just keep all the u23s just in case.

Everyone else is fair game to go I think

I'm not sure what 'decent' is anymore. Every year the price of footballers exceeds predictions and some lunatic bids for players (any club) shocks us all. Plenty go under the radar too. Grant (keepers are the exception I guess) doing so well at Stoke has been incredible. I'm really pleased for him even though it is Stoke. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...