Motson tops list of fans' favourite sports commentators and pundits of all time... but does Savage really belong in the top 10?

[AndyinLiverpool]

I can't imagine why anybody would want to listen to anything at all from the mouth of Robbie Savage.

 

It says a lot about the world of football that there are so few actual journalists on the lists and so many chancers getting a gig simply on the grounds that they are former players rather than their abilities with the spoken word.

[ladyram]

I reckon Sav would be Linekars bromance choice, and he's even got a pet name for him which is Roberta. Aww bless.

[May Contain Nuts]

The fact the survey was on confused.com invalidates the whole thing.

[Alph]

Clarke Carlisle's coverage of the Europa League on ITV4 is by far the worst summarising I have ever heard.

"... a wonderful first touch. The way he brought it down and then got off his shot was top quality"

It was a volley that went 10 yards high and wide. Made me laugh last night.

[Srg]

"... a wonderful first touch. The way he brought it down and then got off his shot was top quality"

It was a volley that went 10 yards high and wide. Made me laugh last night.

 

I loved the part where he was trying to talk about Defoe's goals to games ratio and was just stumbling around without actually having any figures.

[rezner]

Alan Green is in my bottom 1 

[Pearl Ram]

Good shout...erm,.. post. He's a know all tw@t that talks as though he had a career as a player, radio's Eamon Holmes. "http://www.subzerosiam.com/forum/images/smilies/****" alt="****">

[Shuff264]

I like Robbie Savage.

 

Would have liked to see Pat Nevin in there, talks alot of sense.

 

And for worst, its probably Owen.

[trekkie_ram]

Oh, well.. 

 

Gary Neville should be there, the amount of insight he has brought to sky is huge for me

 

and, Jamie Carragher will be there in the future - class pundit. Just says everything is 'awful' 'embarrassing' and loves a reference to his own illustrious penalty kick missing 3rd choice cnuting career 

I read the Gary Neville sentence, and hit 'like'. I then read the Jamie Carragher part - lol - that undid the like for me.

[trekkie_ram]

Can we start the worst 10 list please, I vote for Andy Townsend.

 

Although recently I'd have to agree with Shuff, Owen is so out of place, he's on a par with a female commentator.

[-JW-]

Andy Hinchcliffe is by far and away the worst, but Sky keep giving him more and more gigs.

[Ambitious]

I read the Gary Neville sentence, and hit 'like'. I then read the Jamie Carragher part - lol - that undid the like for me.

 

Jamie Carragher is largely sarcastic - only seen him once and he just moaned like buggery and saying 'I'd of never got away with.. blah, blah, blah' 

 

Neville however, is very good. 

[mozza]

Bring back Andy Gray , i say..

[BondJovi]

Beglin and Tyldesley. Why oh why!!!!

[ladyram]

Bring back Andy Gray , i say..

Nope. He's a sexist get.

[mozza]

Nope. He's a sexist get.

 

 

ha ha , that was funny , no sense of humour some folk..

 

( i've got to  find the clip now )

[ladyram]

He's an arse. Him and his mate.

[Leicester Ram]

Hate to see the sparkling personality of Gareth Southgate miss out

[ramsbottom]

I have no idea what he's called but whoever spoke the following -

"Here's Callaghan. Confronted by Dixon, who's left him with a bit of space. And he might yet pay for that! Here's Gee! SCREAMER!!!"

Is a funking genius!!!

If you have no idea what I'm going on about, you have my sympathies...

[ariotofmyown]

Why isn't Stuart Hall on the list...

He is, but it's more of a register