Ilsonram12

1Wildsmith 6
24Nyambe 7
35Nelson 7
6Cashin 7
3Forsyth 7
Wilson 6
12Smith 5
Bird 🦅  6
22Fornah 7
11Méndez-Laing 5
10Waghorn 5
Washington 6
7Barkhuizen 6
Sibley 6
9Collins 5
Solid in defence, poor in attack, smith and mendez-laing need a time out 

1Wildsmith 6
24Nyambe 7
35Nelson 7
6Cashin 7
3Forsyth 7
Wilson 6
12Smith 5
Bird 🦅  6
22Fornah 7
11Méndez-Laing 5
10Waghorn 5
Washington 6
7Barkhuizen 6
Sibley 6
9Collins 5
Solid in defence, poor in attack, smith and mendez-laing need a time out 

1Wildsmith 6
24Nyambe 7
35Nelson 7
6Cashin 7
3Forsyth 7
Wilson 6
12Smith 5
Bird 🦅  6
22Fornah 7
11Méndez-Laing 5
10Waghorn 5
Washington 6
7Barkhuizen 6
Sibley 6
9Collins 5
Solid in defence, poor in attack, smith and mendez-laing need a time out 

Thanks to those of you who provided player ratings for the Burton Albion match; Apologies that it has taken so long to analyse the data - tempus fugit & all that. Can you even actually remember the game?
Fig 2 shows that statistically James Collins was MotM with an average rating of 7.82. Corey Smith was runner-up with 7.41 & Birdy (my personal MotM) 3rd with 7.14. Team average rating was 6.56 (dotted blue line in chart above); 4 players (Collins, Smith, Bird & Forsyth) were above the team average and everyone from Washington & below were therefore below average. Off the top of my head, that's a fairly typical picture, even with just 11 ratings for this game (there's usually about 22).
Table 1 gives the raters figures in aggregated form. The rater is shown in the first column, and their individual ratings for players along the adjacent 16 columns. There's an aggregate figure for the rater in the final column. The RAG (Red-Amber-Green) rating is by rater showing red for the lowest rating player and dark green for the highest rated player. So you can see that amongst raters there was quite a consensus insofaras Collins, Smith & Bird are consistently rated green by most raters with combinations of red/amber for the other players. 
The aggregated range is quite high though - 14 - which illustrates how different raters are "differently-generous" in their scoring. @@Ilsonram12 gave the most conservative scores and at the other extreme @Topram gave the most generous ("Happy Clapper" or what! 😆). Who is the most reliable? Well that's just opinion.  
 

 I will catch-up with all the other games very soon; and I am going to produce an "running aggregate" and have @Boycie, my favourite Moderator, pin that to the top of the Forum, so that we can keep a far closer eye on Poster's player ratings. 
What's interesting for me right now is that James Collins, who does get stick (as a lot of players do), is starting to emerge this season as a highly-rated (statistically) player which is a tad surprising; but I'm very pleased for him. Nelson too is starting to shine (statistically) after a settling-in period. 
Keep your eyes posted for more ratings results later this week. 
Any questions / additional analyses just ask.  
NB If you click on the chart/table image, you get a "pop-out" graphic which is easier to read. 
 
 
 
 

1Wildsmith 7
24Nyambe 7
35Nelson 7
6Cashin 7
3Forsyth 6
11Méndez-Laing 6
Washington ,6
12Smith 6
22Fornah 7
17Sibley 6
7Barkhuizen 6
10Waghorn 6
Wilson 6
9Collins 8
 

Wildsmith 7
Wilson 8
Bradley 7
Radcliffe 6
Cashin,7
Barkhuizen 7
Washington 6
Collins 6
Sibley 7
Smith, 6
Embleton:6
Mendez-Laing:7
Elder 7
Forsyth 6
Fornah. 7

Dixon Scored ilkestons goal after coming on at half time, coming back from an injury, pick of the ex rams was Paul green for worksop,even at 40yr old he ran the show

At ilkeston town today and they have 4 in Jamie Hanson, Connor Dixon, Nathan Tyson and Matt Yates, worksop have Paul green 

At ilkeston town today and they have 4 in Jamie Hanson, Connor Dixon, Nathan Tyson and Matt Yates, worksop have Paul green 

1Wildsmith 5
34Rooney 6
Bradley 5
35Nelson 6
3Forsyth 6
11Méndez-Laing 5
12Smith 6
6Cashin 6
4Hourihane 6
22Fornah 7
20Elder 6
14Washington 6
Vickers 6
10Waghorn 6
John-Jules 6
Collins 5
RTV

Post of the day 🤛 chopping and changing don't work, there's no magic wand or a McLaren/clough scenario
Last week it was hms piss the league now it's warne ain't got a clue again 🙄

What a Bold comment, How come we aren't keeping clean sheets then?

Bradley is error prone like Keogh and as useless as Albentosa. 

Post of the day 🤛 chopping and changing don't work, there's no magic wand or a McLaren/clough scenario
Last week it was hms piss the league now it's warne ain't got a clue again 🙄

Poor reffing an own goal and 2 stupid mistakes in a minute cost us that, Bolton weren't anything special but we let them play like they were 

Post of the day 🤛 chopping and changing don't work, there's no magic wand or a McLaren/clough scenario
Last week it was hms piss the league now it's warne ain't got a clue again 🙄

Post of the day 🤛 chopping and changing don't work, there's no magic wand or a McLaren/clough scenario
Last week it was hms piss the league now it's warne ain't got a clue again 🙄

Poor reffing an own goal and 2 stupid mistakes in a minute cost us that, Bolton weren't anything special but we let them play like they were 

Signed for Solihull moors in the national League, good luck to the goat 🐐

1Wildsmith 6
34Rooney 6
35Nelson 7
6Cashin 7
11Méndez-Laing 7
14Elder 6
12Smith 7
4Hourihane 7
Forna 6
16Thompson 8
3Forsyth 7
10Waghorn 9
John-Jules 6
14Washington 7
9Collins 6

1Wildsmith 7
35Nelson 6
5Bradley 6
34Rooney 7
14Washington 7
6Cashin 7
12Smith 6
23Waghorn 7
4Hourihane 6
3Forsyth 7
11Méndez-Laing 7
20Elder 6
9Collins 6
16Thompson 8
17Sibley 6
ATG

So why sign Nelson and Bradley? When there's Fozzy and Rooney for cover.
Why sign Wilson and Ward? When again Rooney or Bardell could cover.
Did we need to sign Vickers, or could Loach and an U21 cover?
It's how you spend your budget.
Why sign no pace? No CDM?

Well last season was the worst side as in league positions, so technically this could be the worst if results carry on 

2007 team were unlucky. 
Billy Davies, in my opinion, was a good manager, took a team that should have been relegation favourites to Premier League.  No investment once there meant - his 'friend', who Billy Davies would never not name drop, Alex Ferguson, would have been relegated with.  If we had lost the play off he'd have lasted a few years.  
If we got rid of Warne, Billy would be my number one choice.  Should never have been sacked for what he achieved.  

1Wildsmith 6
35Nelson 5
5Bradley 5
14Washington 6
6Cashin 5
23Ward 4
2Wilson 5
12Smith 4
23Waghorn 6
8Bird 6
4Hourihane 6
3Forsyth:6
11Méndez-Laing 4
20Elder 5
9Collins 4
16Thompson 6