tinman
-
Posts
973 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Reputation Activity
-
tinman reacted to ap04 in Paul Warne
This may ignore the majority who haven't, that correlation doesn't mean causation for those who have, and also the longer term trend.
You may be interested in this research that covered a large period, basically the impact of a change is minimal after an initial "bounce", and that bounce is just the preceding dip in results, quite often due to luck, that led to the change regressing to the mean. There has also been evidence showing the same would happen without a change.
-
tinman reacted to i-Ram in Paul Warne
Difficult for me to say C86. I have not watched many of our performances of late, other than highlights, but notwithstanding I wouldn’t hold Paul Warne to account for any specific game in isolation, whether it Wycombe (A), Northampton (A), or Charlton (H). All 3 of them poor performances recently, with vital points lost, when a win could have created real pressure on teams around us.
I think he had really limited options on Wednesday, but part of that I feel is because he ‘breaks’ players. How many players have we had on the treatment table this season with niggling injuries to soft tissue, hamstrings, calf pulls, etc. He works players too hard in my opinion, prioritising stamina and athleticism over ball retention and passing finesse. Fortunately we have a good, deep squad funded by Clowes, because we need it to cover for the number of injuries that are being sustained. Didn’t I read that he was saying on Tuesday how the players didn’t look right, and how some were jaded on Wednesday evening. I wonder whether he ever thinks it’s because he wears them out with his demands.
I am not a fan of his ‘tactics’ either - conceding midfield and hitting the ball quickly to the wings to get crosses in is ok, if we had a really decent (old fashioned) centre forward to get his head on most of the crosses, and if it wasn’t our only actual tactic (other than loading up at free kicks and corners). Seems to me that when the tactic isn’t working that we just try to do more of the same, but more quickly, with our players treating the football like it’s a hot potato.
In answer to @G STAR RAMand @YorkshireRam being second, per se, is not the problem, and he may well get us up. If he does it would be churlish for me not to say well done, you did your job. The players too. However, he disappoints me as I think we have the best squad overall in the league, and that the league is at its lowest quality for years. When I say in spite of Warne, I mean that I think a decent coach could have got this squad promoted by now, keeping the players fit through better rotation and the use of a few younger lads near the end of games, and playing a better brand of football suiting better the skill set of a number of our players. Rather than having a nail biting finish, we could and should be well clear of the third place team in my opinion.
And that is all it is, my opinion. Not concerned a jot if someone, or everyone, doesn’t agree with it, or doesn’t understand it. Equally I don’t feel the need to strongly debate it either. As you say I have been pretty consistent with my opinion on him since he joined, and I haven’t seen much over the last 18 months that that changes my viewpoint.
-
tinman got a reaction from SKRam in Mystery Announcement? Friday 05/04/24 08:20am
It’ll be something bland like a new pundit for match day.
-
tinman got a reaction from Eoghan1884 in Mystery Announcement? Friday 05/04/24 08:20am
It’ll be something bland like a new pundit for match day.
-
tinman got a reaction from Crewton in Academy thread 23/24
I see James Scanlon’s little brother has signed for Man Utd too.
another case of little brother joining big brother after being forced to leave Derby for the money in previous years.
-
tinman got a reaction from JuanFloEvraTheCocu'sNesta in Coming to Derby. Advice please folks.
Bubbles is a must visit
-
tinman got a reaction from DarkFruitsRam7 in Coming to Derby. Advice please folks.
Bubbles is a must visit
-
tinman got a reaction from Black ('n' White) Sheep in Coming to Derby. Advice please folks.
Bubbles is a must visit
-
tinman got a reaction from The_Sheriff in Coming to Derby. Advice please folks.
Bubbles is a must visit
-
tinman got a reaction from hintonsboots in Coming to Derby. Advice please folks.
Bubbles is a must visit
-
tinman got a reaction from Blackpoolmad in Coming to Derby. Advice please folks.
Bubbles is a must visit
-
-
tinman reacted to Charlie George in Academy thread 23/24
Where has Darren Robinson been playing for the Under 21's ?
Recall him playing at CB against Wolves in the cup. On the bench regularly this season. Perhaps a space has opened up for him in the first team today.
-
-
tinman reacted to Chris_Martin in Paul Warne
the point i was trying to make is that the promotion race is easier than last year
Ipswich, Sheff Wed and Plymouth were both great last season, barely dropping any points. Ipswich are one point off top of the championship
Reading have come down with a points deduction, and have been forced to sell players and can't afford to buy. Blackpool have really struggled this season. Wigan have also struggled at times and had to sell players. They also have had a points deduction this season.
Barnsley, Bolton, Peterborough are all kind of where they were last season. Which really just leaves Portsmouth who have improved in comparison to last season
So overall, it is clearly easier to get near top of the league this season
-
tinman reacted to InstaRam in Paul Warne
Credit to where it's due. This was more of how I would have thought we would play this season. Keep it up now lads!
-
-
-
-
tinman reacted to IlsonDerby in Paul Warne
I’d love to see this squad of players coached well. That’s all.
If Warne stays on as cheerleader then replace his coaches.
-
tinman got a reaction from Crewton in v Charlton Athletic (H) Match Day Thread
Genuinely one thing that gets me angry is how many times the players ’first touch sends in the air to head height when they’re trying to control a pass.
-
-
tinman got a reaction from DiggerB in v Charlton Athletic (H) Match Day Thread
Genuinely one thing that gets me angry is how many times the players ’first touch sends in the air to head height when they’re trying to control a pass.
-
tinman got a reaction from Steve Buckley’s Dog in v Charlton Athletic (H) Match Day Thread
Genuinely one thing that gets me angry is how many times the players ’first touch sends in the air to head height when they’re trying to control a pass.
-